2 ms·
I am not a lawyer - I would appreciate it if a lawyer could confirm or reject my understanding - I think it's actually the opposite (but take this with a grain
by gpm 8y ago
I am not a lawyer - I would appreciate it if a lawyer could confirm or reject my understanding - I think it's actually the opposite (but take this with a grain of salt):
This would be a derivative work of the material it is quoting. Derivative works aren't protected by both the original copyright and the copyright of the person who prepared the derivative work, only the latter. Since the US government does not gain a copyright on derivative works that means the entire derivative work is in the public domain. You can make copies of it, distribute it, prepare further derivative works (such as cutting out everything except the poem! Though maybe not a good idea to test that plan), etc.
The only exception to this would be (I think) if the report was created in violation of copyright law, but there's no way that this would not be found to be fair use. All the standard factors are in it's favor. There is a strong public good in it's favor.
- Meph504 8y agoFirstly not a attorney, but have spend the last several years working hand and hand with a large number specifically related to these issues. My take away is as follows Including copyrighted material in its entirety and original form in a different work does not make it derivative. It's original copyright stands. A quick requirement for derivative work. The derivative work must demonstrate transformation, modification or adaptation of the original work must be substantial and bear its author's personality sufficiently to be original and thus protected by copyright.