3 ms·
That is, to pass for a human, the AI should imitate humans. This includes imitating their mistakes. AI's genuine mistakes would likely be different enough to he
by nine_k 8y ago
That is, to pass for a human, the AI should imitate humans. This includes imitating their mistakes. AI's genuine mistakes would likely be different enough to help humans tell an AI from a human.
That is, the best strategy for an AI to pass the test is to be perfect, and perfectly imitate a perfect amount of human mistakes.
This definitely requires an ability to lie, to knowingly tell untrue things.
This ability is also required by much simpler circumstances: when directly asked, an AI should be able to lie and say "No, I'm a human", else it will fail the test instantly.
This likely means that a robot following the Asimov's three laws would never pass a direct Turing test.
- antpls 8y ago> This likely means that a robot following the Asimov's three laws would never pass a direct Turing test. Not necessarily true. An AI could pretend that it doesn't follow Asimov's laws while in fact following them. For example, the AI could pretend that, to execute the given order (second law), it first needs to understand the author psychology. At that point the AI can change the author's mind by using persuasive tactics. If the AI successfully changed author's mind, it successfully didn't follow the initial order by simply cancelling it with consent of the author The first and third laws are also applicable to humans, and cannot be used to detect the AI