From the people you named, it seems clear to me you do not know what I mean by left. Celebrities that play lip service to social issues for PR value, sure, but

From the people you named, it seems clear to me you do not know what I mean by left. Celebrities that play lip service to social issues for PR value, sure, but that's easy. Now tell me how many of the same people advocate for single payer, or ending the war in Yemen, my guess is almost none of them. That's social vs economic left for you. Being socially liberal is logical, gays are also your customers. It's a different story when it comes to economics.