5 ms·
I liked the opening of "The Gods Must Be Crazy", in particular when they say "But he didn't know when to stop." Here's the part of the script comparing the sim
by m463 8y ago
I liked the opening of "The Gods Must Be Crazy", in particular when they say "But he didn't know when to stop."
Here's the part of the script comparing the simple lives of the native bushmen of the Kalahari desert to "civilized man":
These Bushmen have never seen a stone or a rock in their lives.
The hardest things they know are wood and bone.
They live in a gentle world, where nothing is as hard as rock, steel or concrete.
Only miles to the south, there's a vast city.
And here you find civilized man.
Civilized man refused to adapt himself to his environment.
Instead he adapted his environment to suit him.
So he built cities, roads, vehicles, machinery.
And he put up power lines to run his labour-saving devices.
But he didn't know when to stop.
The more he improved his surroundings to make life easier...
...the more complicated he made it.
Now his children are sentenced to years of school, to learn...
...how to survive in this complex and hazardous habitat.
And civilized man, who refused to adapt to his surroundings...
...now finds he has to adapt and re-adapt...
...every hour of the day to his self-created environment.
- projektir 8y agoThis largely relies on the idea that pre-civilized life was preferable. And, for some groups, it was. All the women enjoying close to 0 sexual freedom and dying in child birth might disagree, though.
- JulianMorrison 8y agoPatriarchy is a farming-age invention.
- projektir 8y agoI am pretty sure menstruation and child birth are not farming age inventions.
- JulianMorrison 8y agoYou'd be surprised. Longer breastfeeding suppresses ovulation and menstruation, so fertility is relatively rare. Childbirth works better squatting. Humans evolved to be hunter gatherers, most of our history is pre-settled-agriculture, we do fit that lifestyle better. And patriarchy was never contingent on those things anyhow. It's just a cultural choice that got stuck because it was woven into the form of citified civilization.
- contraryBecause 8y agoSo, I guess you're cool with the Darwinian aspect of childbirth, where we just let women bite it on their own, because if they can't survive the birthing process they must've been unfit organisms? And oh yeah, what about that part where, as part of nomadic life (you know, living in undefended tents, encampments, shanty towns, what have you), guys can pretty much just take what they want when push comes to shove, and inseminate women according to any opportunity available (see also: orangutan mating strategies), like, you know, when it's dark at night and everyone's trying to sleep and no one is looking. And before you retort that such a thing is easier said than done, consider that the definition of success is not living well after the act of conception. As long as the proverbial toilet gets flushed, the pregnancy was mostly a runaway train, with few reliable undo buttons. How do those aspects of sex differences fit into your world view of the old dastardly, dastardly patriarchy?
- projektir 8y ago> Longer breastfeeding suppresses ovulation and menstruation, so fertility is relatively rare. > Childbirth works better squatting. I would like to see citations indicating that these statements are true to a significant degree that modern improvements are of little value. I can't even find data on maternal mortality before 1800.
- walterstucco 8y agoWhile some of it it's true, especially the longer breastfeeding cycles, hunter gatherers were very exposed to natural dangers and groups were very small and vulnerable: a sickness or an accident could whipe them away overnight.
- 8y ago
- buttcoinslol 8y agoDo you mean in the sense that hunter-gatherer prehistorical cultures tended to be more egalitarian?
- m463 8y agowait, hold up. The point was "knowing when to stop". Civilization creates these juggernauts that start moving and when they reach their goals their momentum carries them past need and reason. How many laws do we need? Do we need more roads (or lanes)? Should taxes increase? in percentage!? Do we need to "add value" to every product ever? Do kids need more homework? Do you need another iPhone?
- Atari800-YC 8y agoNo, but I might like to have another Atari 800.
- projektir 8y agoI'd say that passage says a lot more things than that, and I'm responding to them. It's part of the fairly resilient narrative of "it was better before" that I think is extremely not true. In my view, it is also nonetheless still not good enough, so I don't want it to "stop", depending on what you are defining as "it" here. Most problems we currently face are not a result of civilization itself. Count of laws or roads doesn't seem very material to me. Adding value treadmills just indicate some failure points of capitalism. But everything else we had before was even worse. What is the purpose of this exposition? We have many problems to fix, but none of them will get fixed by going backwards.
- perl4ever 8y agoI never bought my first iPhone. I am however, not at the point at which I feel like the world should stop turning. I'm more like "ok, I am capable of selecting the good things from the bad, and letting go of the novel tech I don't like". Perhaps that is a product of being middle aged and I will feel differently when I am 80. Douglas Adams wrote: “I've come up with a set of rules that describe our reactions to technologies: 1. Anything that is in the world when you’re born is normal and ordinary and is just a natural part of the way the world works. 2. Anything that's invented between when you’re fifteen and thirty-five is new and exciting and revolutionary and you can probably get a career in it. 3. Anything invented after you're thirty-five is against the natural order of things.” I like to look at classic car ads, and I saw one for a car from the 60s or whatever, and I forget the exact phrasing, but it said it had had a modern type of stereo installed, which had AM/FM and a CD player. Which I thought was funny, because that kind of pinpoints the assumed age/generation of a buyer. Going by Adams, someone who thinks car CDs are new, but good, could have been up to 35 in 1985 when the first car CD players came out. Which is exactly the age to remember mid to late 60s cars as desirable as a teenager. But now they are close to 70 years old, and that's why the prices of such cars are trending down. I'm not sure that it's inevitable that you hate new things as you get older. Maybe it's more that people feel insecure about their ability to choose which new things they like, because it becomes a disorienting flood.
- perl4ever 8y agoI think that it's the same phenomenon as happens in many species, where something like horns starts from a random mutation and then becomes attractive to others, resulting in a runaway selection based on competing for mates right up until it becomes counterproductive enough. It's not something profoundly unique to Homo Sapiens. Interestingly, I found the following link which mentions that there is a form of tumor in humans (that may or may not be benign) which produces horn-like protrusions. Obviously this is not generally considered attractive, but if it were, society would change! https://www.quora.com/How-can-natural-selection-explain-the-evolution-of-horns-in-mammals https://www.quora.com/How-can-natural-selection-explain-the-...
- dfee 8y agoOff topic, but this looks like a great film. I always struggle to find worthwhile movies to watch, so thanks!