4 ms·
It's really amazing how AA and airspeed are so... difficult for pilots to perceive that they're totally reliant on the sensors to tell them. Speed I guess make
by duxup 8y ago
It's really amazing how AA and airspeed are so... difficult for pilots to perceive that they're totally reliant on the sensors to tell them.
Speed I guess makes sense, just amazing how a pilot so easily can slow a plane too much, change the angle too much and have no idea what is up.
- bwilliams18 8y agoAngle of Attack doesn't refer to the angle of the plane relative to the horizon but the angle of the plane relative to airflow.
- nosianu 8y agoTo illustrate further using the most extreme example I can think of - flying a loop: The angle of attack will remain in its usual very narrow range at any point when you fly a loop. The critical or stalling angle of attack is typically around 15° - 20° for many airfoils (so your AoA should be less than that). Note that if you fly upside down (negative-G capable aerobatics airplane) you will still have a positive AoA, just on the other side of the wing. > If the airplane you’re flying is equipped with an angle-of-attack indicator, it will illustrate an abstract concept that pilots learn to recite during ground school but rarely fully comprehend—which is that an airplane can stall in “any attitude” and at “any airspeed.” For me, it took stalling on the back side of a loop (while pointed straight down at a high power setting) for that idea to sink in. https://www.aopa.org/news-and-media/all-news/2013/may/pilot/technique-learning-to-loop https://www.aopa.org/news-and-media/all-news/2013/may/pilot/...
- ummonk 8y agoEh, that would generally be considered a negative angle of attack, since we arbitrarily label one side of the wing as positive direction.
- nosianu 8y agoAs a private pilot who has done a bit of aerobatics, I disagree. It still is a positive AoA. Using a negative would be in conflict with what you would mean when you mean.. well, a negative AoA, for example when people ask questions such as this one: https://aviation.stackexchange.com/questions/51477/do-negative-angles-of-attack-create-lift https://aviation.stackexchange.com/questions/51477/do-negati... I would use AoA in relation to the direction of flight, not the up or down orientation of the airplane. Even upside down I still fly quite normally (in straight & level upside-down flight), and the lift created is positive: Up/down in relation to the earth don't change, so the direction of lift does not change. In this context it would be a bit confusing to use negative numbers as you suggest, IMO. However, since you can set your relative coordinate system and context however you like this is a topic we could discuss this ad infinitum without convincing one another if we insist on our respective PoVs. When faced with the linked question you would have some more explaining to do though, because there are negative AoA and no upside-down flight (now imagine adding that to the question to make it even more confusing...) :)
- ummonk 8y agoThe linked example provides a good reason you should use negative AoA. It would be ridiculous to have a discontinuity in AoA jumping -5 to +5 just because the direction of lift changes slightly.
- nosianu 8y agoThe direction of lift does not change at all. It still is UP. That is the point.
- lutorm 8y agoNo, as long as you are pulling positive G's, your angle of attack is positive. It has nothing to do with pitch angle. Edit: Oh you meant flying upside down, not doing a loop? Yeah, negative AoA is not the same as positive AoA. It makes sense to distinguish them because, unless the wing uses a symmetric airfoil, it will behave differently in the two cases. Given that you also calculate the lift vector as a function of AoA, and for anything to make sense the lift vector is antiparallel in the two cases, the AoA would also be negative.
- briandear 8y agoUnder VFR what you say is true, under Instrument conditions the AoA indication is critically important. Once you’re in a cloud, you literally can’t tell which way is up without instruments and the AoA is an essential part.
- 7952 8y agoNot every airliner even shows AOA, it is just used as input for stall warnings and the flight recorder. It should be possible to fly safely using pitch and air speed indicators. And even a loss of air speed should be survivable by using known good configurations.
- zzless 8y agoIt depends very much on the circumstances. In most slow GA airplanes (and yes, the Vision jet is a slow plane), one can perceive both the airspeed and the angle of attack by the control feel ("mushy" vs "firm"). Many older airplanes (for example the fastest GA piston twin, the Aerostar 601P) did not have even stall indicators. That airplane used to scare the crap out of me during a takeoff on a hot day. Everything had to be done just right ... You mostly need a stall indicator or an AoA during tricky procedures like really short field operations (which in the Aerostar world translates to "just don't"). Jets are a slightly different story however I do not believe the VJ gets fast enough for that to matter.
- AdrianB1 8y agoMost GA pilots are not reliant on sensors, we learn to fly with no instruments. Most airline pilots fly on instruments and almost never without. My instructor told me in the school I will have to learn to know the speed without looking anywhere but feeling it from the way the plane flies. He is right. Flying too much on instruments is taking away the feel of the plane, there are skills you can train and hone and there are skills you loose due to lack of use.
- heelix 8y agoHelped on a ferry flight of an aerobatics plane from Denver area to Chicago area. The front half I was in had a ball compass, altimeter, and airspeed indicator. It has been a long time since I've been in something without any electronics. The dumb and ugly was strong when I started to chase the compass rather than look outside. :)