6 ms·
No machine is an island. You can’t send anybody an Atari 800 floppy disk, or bring that floppy somewhere, and expect it to be read. An Atari 800 does not have
by teddyh 8y ago
No machine is an island. You can’t send anybody an Atari 800 floppy disk, or bring that floppy somewhere, and expect it to be read. An Atari 800 does not have a USB port. You can’t browse the modern web on an Atari 800. And all of those things are what people do now. The computer did not, by itself, become worse, but the world around it changed, and the computer did not change with the times. The computer is therefore unusable for any normal activity which people want to do, and the normal term for that is, indeed, “obsolete”.
- themodelplumber 8y agoEdited: Duplicate
- themodelplumber 8y agoAgain, if your reference point is the "normalized" market, that's the only way obsolescence really works as a model. This requires little effort to understand. What I'm saying is, think about the long tail and the extraction of value from this technology. It's far from incapable. I don't know about you, but I could plan a global economic takeover on an 800; still can. I can also teach someone else to do so. In fact, it's easier to stay focused. There's no malware and comparatively little practical need for encryption. We waste a lot of qualitative profit as we march forward in search of breadth. Here we are robbed blind by the obsolescence model, which imparts heavy bias to our thinking.
- TheOtherHobbes 8y agoIt's obsolete in the way a horse is obsolete. If you have a specific job - getting to the next town, or maybe crossing the continental USA - it will do that job, or at least attempt to. But it will be painfully slow, unreliable, and potentially expensive compared to more modern alternatives. No one is really being robbed here - because there's a point where incremental changes in technology mean that a product becomes qualitatively different. Not just faster, but able to do things that an older product can't. In this example the qualitative differences are obvious. You can't make calls, watch videos, browse the web, develop modern software, play modern games, write modern documents, or print them with a modern printer. You can still do some very simple programming on it, but you can't share the code without hard-to-find extras. So - obsolete. It's capable of some extremely limited applications, none of which are particularly useful. And it's quite useless for anything else.
- MisterTea 8y ago> ... unreliable ... I'm sure that machine will still power on after in 20 years. Try that with today's flimsy throwaway junk.
- chillacy 8y agoWhy design for 20 years when it’ll be unusable in 5? If anything we need more biodegradable parts, and bottles that last 10 years not 500 years.
- JohnFen 8y ago> Why design for 20 years when it’ll be unusable in 5? I can't think of any modern machines that will be unusable in 5 years. Even my smartphone is 7 years old and still perfectly fine. Until a few years back, I regularly used an old Cromemco System III computer that was built in 1979 (it has since been donated to a computer museum).
- japanoise 8y ago>Until a few years back, I regularly used an old Cromemco System III computer that was built in 1979 Please don't take this as sneering -because I'm genuinely interested in late 70s micros!- but what did you use the system 3 for? Can you tell me about it as a computer? It's not a computer I know much about and I'm interested in what you would've used it for, especially recently.
- JohnFen 8y agoIt was a z80-based CP/M machine. I got it as payment for a software project I did for someone. I used it for recreational/hobby activities. I forget the system clock speed, but I think it was around 2 MHz. The thing was made of steel, weighed over 100lbs, and contained 4 8-inch floppy drives (combined capacity for all four was about 2.5 megs, I think, but it may have been 5). The one I had contained an insane 512 megs of RAM. If I remember correctly, the one I had was purchased new for somewhere in the neighborhood of $10,000 (1979, which is about $35,000 today). This was, at the time, serious hardware. It even did high-resolution graphics that would (barely) still be considered high-resolution today. Turning it on literally made my lights dim momentarily and sounded like a jet engine spooling up. It was glorious. Nothing about it is practical in today's terms, of course. I had fun doing things like writing compilers and software to use it as the coordinator for a crazy project I was engaging in at the time: I had networked 10 Kaypro IIs together with it and was using the entire combined system as a single multi-CPU computing machine. What I mostly did with it, though, was to experiment with hardware. The System III was an S-100 bus machine, and did not even have a motherboard as we think of them these days. It had a backplane that you installed cards into to provide all functionality. This made it really fun and easy to experiment with changes that would, in a modern machine, have required altering the motherboard.
- rbanffy 8y ago> You can’t send anybody an Atari 800 floppy disk, or bring that floppy somewhere, and expect it to be read. An Atari 800 does not have a USB port Actually, not only you can use an SD card as mass storage without much effort, thanks to the many people who build modern peripherals for the SIO bus, but you can probably telnet and ssh as much as you want from it (smart modem-like network interfaces). If I wanted, my Atari XE (mostly an 800, slightly modernized) could easily be used for light local text editing.
- teddyh 8y agoIf you buy modern hardware to do modern things, why not also buy a modern keyboard and monitor and cut the 800 out completely? Especially since modern web browsing pretty much requires more pixels and colors than the 800 can produce.
- kalleboo 8y agoYeah it looks like the SD card reader adapters have more computing power than the Atari 800 itself. So why even bother with the Atari?
- perl4ever 8y agoWell, one possible reason that you might not have thought of is that modern hardware (and software!) has so many hidden layers that you never know what you are running. Like PCs have Minix, and CPUs besides the main CPU, and so on. So you might look at something old like the Atari 800 and say, well, I know basically what it is. By comparison, a modern PC is like the horror movie trope of a thin humanoid skin over writhing innards. Because computers are so cheap and tiny that a device has vastly more than you are aware of. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_Management_Engine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_Management_Engine Some people are taking classic cars and converting them to electric power, without changing the fact that they are basically un-aerodynamic deathtraps and without even getting rid of the manual transmission. That may not be what you consider optimum, but it is logical given some peoples' values.
- perl4ever 8y agoI had an old PowerBook that hadn't been used in years, which had a PowerPC chip, and I had the impression that it was useless, because you need a new web browser to view current websites, and Apple does not provide updates for such machines. However, I did find a distribution of Linux that booted to a GUI, although as usual there seemed to be issues with power management which might have been software or hardware. So, I'm saying you can't forget that any computer is probably more useful than you think, given suitable software. These days, it should be easier than ever to make an interface for something weird, given the resources for hobbyists like FPGAs. I remember 15-20 years ago, when I had access to a "Fat" Mac 512K which had pretty much no software including an OS, and I wondered if I could do something with it, because I had recently been learning about Linux. I didn't go very far with the experiment, but I copied some minimal hand assembled bootstrap code to the boot sector of a floppy (avoiding any problems with the drive being unreliable at reading large amounts of data) and then I rewired a Mac printer cable to connect it to the PC serial port, and I got the Mac to download an image to its framebuffer. I didn't have the motivation or stick-to-it-ivness to continue, but I had the vision at the time of a Mac as a terminal for Linux.