3 ms·
The web can be controlled. It's just much harder and expensive to do so. But what China should be worrying about is whether it can keep controlling the people
by chrischen 16y ago
The web can be controlled. It's just much harder and expensive to do so.
But what China should be worrying about is whether it can keep controlling the people in general. As the government begins to meet basic human needs, the citizens will start to yearn for higher needs to be satisfied like freedom of information. The government cannot provide that and continue it's authoritarian regime.
- DannoHung 16y agoThe web can only be controlled so long as it's a wired affair. If the concept of a wireless mesh can be realized, it's game over for anything but a silly illusion of control.
- Groxx 16y agoAnd if one controls the technology which creates the mesh? ie, requires a back-door into every device?
- rgrieselhuber 16y agoExcellent point. Vintage networking hardware could start to become quite valuable.
- Natsu 16y agoAssuming it's still compatible with anything else at that point. Honestly, though? With cheap mass storage, we could end up going all the way down to sneakernet. They really could do a lot more to control the internet. Not fully, of course. It can't ever be fully controlled. But they really could do a lot to put us into an age of digital prohibition.
- alexqgb 16y agoThat cost becomes a big deal when you're competing with people who decide not to tax their creative populations in the same way. Unfortunately for Americans, there's a huge gap between what we consider unacceptable, and what China disallows. That means the US tax can go up considerably before becoming uncompetitive. At the same time getting into the "how stupid can you be and still come out ahead?" race opens up tremendous opportunity for others who are far more nimble, and are only too happy to place bets on which economic superpower will choke itself first.
- quanticle 16y ago>As the government begins to meet basic human needs, the citizens will start to yearn for higher needs to be satisfied like freedom of information. Really? I mean, its nice to paraphrase Maslow and all, but what evidence do you have that it will actually turn out that way? At least, here in the US, the citizenry seems to be tolerating a government that becomes more authoritarian with regards to freedom of information and rights against unreasonable searches. I do hope that things do turn out the way you envision. My fear is that you're seeing inevitability where I see historical caprice.