6 ms·
Bitcoin was built with a really narrow ideological view of money (that limited supply of money is good) built on a fallacy (that current money is fake money cre
by littlestymaar 8y ago
Bitcoin was built with a really narrow ideological view of money (that limited supply of money is good) built on a fallacy (that current money is fake money created by governments, when in reality it's created by the banking system through credit). It's not “sound money” it's more like «libertarian dream money», and so far it failed at becoming a money (e.g. something you would buy stuff with), because of the scarcity, which leads to automatic deflation.
- mrb 8y ago"so far it failed at becoming a money" Bitpay (one of the largest Bitcoin payment processors in the world) processed a record $1 billion in transactions in 2018. This impressive increase of people using Bitcoin to buy real-world products and services shows Bitcoin is doing very well as "money": https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20190116005701/en/BitPay-Sees-Record-Year-Revenue-2018-1 https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20190116005701/en/Bit...
- shkkmo 8y ago1 billion is what, about 1% of supply of bitcoin? So less than that since this includes bitcoin cash as well? > In the past year, the BitPay wallet added integrations with major gift card brands, enabling users to buy gift cards in-app for travel, food, and shopping with Bitcoin and Bitcoin Cash. They don't break out what types of goods/services are being purchased. I wonder to what percentage of their transaction are being used to sell / launder bitcoins associated with illegal activity by buying gift cards that can then be resold.
- intertextuality 8y agoNot sure why you're being downvoted here; I also would like to see a breakdown of what people are actually buying with bitcoin thru BitPay. To this day I still don't know anyone in real life who actually uses it over any other payment method.
- Ibethewalrus 8y agoMy 2c: its the 2-3 whales controlling 90%, just bouncing coins around. Hoping to build hype again
- littlestymaar 8y agoWhat you need to look at is the ratio between the amount in circulation and how much is spent every year. For $1billon in bitcoin this figure is ≈1%. For dollar (I'll take MZM[1] to provide a conservative result, but it would be even higher if you took M0 or just cash), this ratio is over 120%! So really, bitcoin isn't really used as money, and mainly as a highly speculative financial asset. Also, $1 billion sounds huge, but for a payment medium it's still really low: worldwide, last year that's also the order of magnitude of the transactions made in Vanuatu vatu. As a comparison, PayPal recorded more than 500 billions dollars in transactions last year. [1] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/WMZMNS https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/WMZMNS
- firethief 8y agoThere are plenty of reasons it has failed at entering general usage, but deflation isn't even a probable contender.
- aey 8y agoImagine I was offering you a way to own piece of a “giant art”. This particular art takes 100 terra-joules of electricity to build. It’s the biggest one in the world. There are enough people in the world that would pay a non zero sum for it. That’s the crux of store of value. The bitcoin data structure has inherent non zero value just based on the audacious amount of electricity to build it.
- intertextuality 8y agoThat has no value at all. Nobody cares that it took "so much energy" to mine that bitcoin block, otherwise bitcoin value would rise infinitely as the mining difficulty increases. Bitcoin has no inherent value. None. Zilch. Nada. We assign it value completely arbitrarily, hence it going from pennies per bitcoin, to $20k, to $4k.
- littlestymaar 8y agoNothing as any inherent value either though. Gold can't be eaten and food is worth nothing when you just had a feast. Value is a social construction highly dependent on the context.
- sparkie 8y agoThe value of bitcoin isn't how much energy it took to create, but how much energy it would take to steal. By being energy intensive, it ensures that an attacker or malicious agent who wishes steal it, or install an involuntary tax on its users, is unable to do so without consuming at least an equivalent amount of energy. If they fail to muster up the majority of the energy, they end up wasting money on electricity spent. The bigger the cost of "electricity wasted" through mining, the bigger the risk the potential attacker must take to attempt to undermine its security. So turns out there are some people who want to save money without it being involuntarily taxed (through forced inflation), and that itself is valuable. Bitcoin has inherent value, and unlike the fiat money it is competing with, that value cannot be arbitrarily adjusted by a monopoly control of money printers, but it is dictated entirely by supply and demand in a free market. The "BTC/USD" exchange rate is not the value of bitcoin, but is a big distraction. If you are tied up in thinking of bitcoin in dollar cost you will end up being the greater fool who only buys when the price is rising rapidly because of FOMO. Or instead, you might be the greatest fool, who resists it until the last possible moment when you realize the world has moved on and nobody wants paper money anymore.
- intertextuality 8y agoDeflation is not why bitcoin didn't become a currency; transaction fees had a huge role in it. Imagine having currency but needing to spend $15, $25, $35 per transaction. That was the reality last year. This coupled with the insane hype that bitcoin received (to the point that random people in my friend circles were discussing it), caused people to not use it as a currency at all, but as a hoard. Now with fees back to normal, time will tell if bitcoin will gain adoption as a currency or if it's too late.
- littlestymaar 8y agoNot only this, but the whole concept of awaiting half an hour to be sure the transactions is confirmed makes it a terrible payment system IRL. But in the long run, the deflationary nature of bitcoin dooms it.
- sparkie 8y agoBitcoin alone doesn't make the greatest payment system, but it needs comparing to gold for its best physical analogue. With physical gold, confirming it takes expertise, special equipment and time. It has a huge attack surface for fraud, which is why it is impractical for everyday payments. Bitcoin is superior to gold in many regards: it is very easy to validate, it requires no physical storage, it is very cheap to transport, and very easy to divide. The systems which are being built on top of bitcoin will enable the use of the currency in practical payment systems: instant transactions, very low fees, and automation - some of which on a scale which was never previously possible because of the high cost of payments in existing payment systems. Systems like the Lightning Network will enable the creation of brand new economies which were simply not possible to do before bitcoin. In terms of deflation, bitcoin is also more similar to gold - it cannot simply be created out of thin air, and must consume energy to extract from the earth. The deflationary nature of bitcoin, and gold before it, make it an excellent store of value, even if it is not the most practical solution for national economies which, according to Keynesians, require stimulation through inflation. The money people are using for their payment systems does not necessarily need to be backed 1-1 by real bitcoin. We can already see some services like conbase are taking custody of people's money, offering debit cards to consumers and Point-of-Sale services to merchants. These will enable the everyday use of bitcoin without any strain on the bitcoin network, and without it necessarily being backed 100% by actual bitcoin. These may benefit their users by providing convenience, but can only work for as long as the providers are sufficiently responsible as to not become insolvent. There are plenty of people who will refuse to use such "fiat bitcoin" services, and will only ever use bitcoin proper. This makes it kind of difficult for conbase and the like, whose fiat bitcoin will end up trading at a lower rate than bitcoin proper - and who will probably try to counter this damage by preventing withdrawal of bitcoin proper from their digital coffers, making their fiat bitcoin only spendable to merchants who will accept fiat bitcoins. They are essentially, trying to recreate the existing banking system on Bitcoin. There's a big difference between the banking system and bitcoin though, and that is permission. Nobody needs permission to use bitcoin proper, and given the choice of fiat bitcoin or bitcoin proper, those with sense will choose the latter. It doesn't matter that bitcoin is deflationary, because people will always act in their own best interest and acquire the most saleable currency, which will continue to be bitcoin proper. The opponents of deflation think that somebody ought to dictate the supply of currency, or that individuals should act against their own self-interest for the good of the many, but this is just a complete ignoring of the reality of human nature. People will always act in their own interest, and deflation is beneficial to ones own interest if they are intent on saving money. Unlike historical events where governments have threatened to send in their henchmen if people don't surrender their gold, bitcoin can not so easily be seized. Bitcoin does not care if you think that deflation is bad, or whether you think "expert economists" ought to decide how much inflation there should be. They are absolutely powerless against the force of Bitcoin. Everybody is. Nobody can control it, but everybody controls it through their own selfish interests. If this happens to lead to people accumulating and spending less, and this leads to economic depression, then that's what will happen! It might make you uncomfortable to think that you are no longer in control, but you're going to have to get over it. The die has been cast. If economic depressions end up occurring as a result deflation in bitcoin, we'll just have to find new ways of dealing with it, because Keynsian's forever money printing method has run its course.