4 ms·
I'm sure I'm in the minority here for thinking this (and by all means, downmod away) but Stallman is clearly a touch insane. His obsession with free software is
by mattmaroon 19y ago
I'm sure I'm in the minority here for thinking this (and by all means, downmod away) but Stallman is clearly a touch insane. His obsession with free software is far beyond the bounds of reason. The Windows on XO issue aside, disabling Wi-Fi just to not run one proprietary piece of code is silly, even if you wouldn't use Wi-Fi anyway.
Everyone needs a religion I guess, even people who surf the web by sending mail to demons.
- xirium 19y ago> His obsession with free software is far beyond the bounds of reason. He's far-sighted and he defends rights before they become important to the mainstream. He has taken what some people view as an extreme position because if he was more moderate then those rights would be more easily eroded. When the Lispers at the MIT AI Lab split into two proprietary factions ( http://www.freemedialibrary.com/index.php/Chapter_7:_A_Stark_Moral_Choice http://www.freemedialibrary.com/index.php/Chapter_7:_A_Stark... ), Richard Stallman stayed behind and wrote an open source version of their developments. You may have a descendant of this code installed on your desktop. When Richard Stallman's story called The Right To Read appeared in the Feb 1997 issue of The Communications Of The ACM ( http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/right-to-read.html http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/right-to-read.html ), people thought this was an unlikely dystopian future. However, 11 years later, DRM is a real and present situation which affects anyone who uses a DVD player, a Tivo, an iPod, an iPhone, a Kindle and Windows Media Player - and many more who don't.
- greyman 19y agoI modded you up. In my opinion it is good to have an XP in OLPC. Children can learn Windows, which is a de-facto standard in corporate world, so they will be prepared better for their professional future.
- xirium 19y agoI'm not modding you but I strongly disagree. > Children can learn Windows, which is a de-facto standard in corporate world, so they will be prepared better for their professional future. Teaching a seven year child how to use XP is of no benefit because XP will be obsolete before the child leaves school. The de-facto argument is circular and isn't in the best interests of the child.
- mattmaroon 19y agoI think it's good to have the option. I can't really have a problem with kids being able but not forced to use Windows. XP might not still be in action by the time they graduate to a normal PC, but it will probably somewhat resemble whichever one does.
- xirium 19y agoThere's plenty of open source software that resembles XP. Why not use that? Indeed, the initial version of OLPC was designed specifically to be below the specification to run XP and now Microsoft has a small team hacking up the stock version of XP so that it will run in a smaller space and with less processing power. Even then, as I understand, an XP install requires an additional 1GB memory stick. This increases price, decreases the number of children who benefit, decreases the "de-facto" aspect and allows proprietary interests to jeopardise the initiative. All this is for the benefit of cautious beaucrats who can easily find other reasons against purchase.
- mattmaroon 19y agoWell, there is a near infinite amount of freeware and shareware that only runs on Windows. Why not give people access to that? I can't see any reason not to give people the option. I guess I don't view it the same way because I'm not as anti-proprietary. The goal of the XO seems, to me, not so much to further open source software (it hardly needs the help) but to further the education of the poor. I don't see how giving them more options could not do so.