2 ms·
One thing I really don’t get about MCAS: even disregarding all its bugs, it seems like a really awful style of envelope protection. I’m neither a pilot not an
by amluto 8y ago
One thing I really don’t get about MCAS: even disregarding all its bugs, it seems like a really awful style of envelope protection. I’m neither a pilot not an expert, but I can imagine several more reasonable strategies when the pilot pulls up too hard: ignore the problematic yoke input, offset the elevators a bit, or apply more force to the yoke. Moving the stabilizer out of trim seems totally wrong.
As an analogy: almost every car has envelope protection. But no car designer in their right mind would build an ABS system that responded to wheel lock by moving the brake pedal or loosening the master cylinder (and not putting it back!). Similarly, it would be crazy for a stability control system to counter oversteer by offsetting the steering wheel (and leaving it offset).
- cjbprime 8y agoElevator probably isn't powerful enough to avoid the impending stall once you get there.
- cjbprime 8y ago... and the 737 MAX control surfaces are mechanical. I don't think there is any ability to ignore yoke input! It's connected to the elevator with a cable. This isn't an Airbus-style fly by wire aircraft where input signals are being interpreted as suggestions for actions for a computer to take.