2 ms·
> That theory is widely disputed. Fair point. But it was accepted by the Muller Report, and therefore Muller decided to not even TRY to prosecute Mr. Trump. (S
by dragontamer 8y ago
> That theory is widely disputed.
Fair point. But it was accepted by the Muller Report, and therefore Muller decided to not even TRY to prosecute Mr. Trump. (See the introduction of Volume II of the report).
Perhaps one day, the theory will be tested. But for now, Muller didn't even want to test that theory. He moved forward assuming it was true.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> But it was accepted by the Muller Report Incorrect, or at best misleading; the Mueller report only accepted that the Office of Special Counsel was, by the terms of it's creation, bound by a pre-existing DoJ (Office of Legal Counsel) determination to that effect; that is, Mueller was not permitted to prosecute due to the existence of the OLC determination and the terms of Mueller's appointment, irrespective of the correctness of the OLC opinion as to whether DoJ had the power to prosecute.
- dragontamer 8y agoI'm not necessarily saying that Muller believes in that theory... only that he was operating under that theory within the context of the report. Perhaps my word "acceptance" was a poor choice. But I want to emphasize that Muller did not fight against that theory. Whether he was unable to, or whether he believed the theory is a separate issue. The important bit is that the Muller Report operated under the assumption that they couldn't indict a sitting President. Considering that something like 10 pages of the report looks like its dedicated to the constitutional powers of Congress (Article I vs Article II issues), it seems like the report is basically saying "This is Congress's issue, not Muller's issue. But here's the evidence Muller found."
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Considering that something like 10 pages of the report looks like its dedicated to the constitutional powers of Congress It's largely discussng the Constitutional power of Congress to criminalize the conduct, which relates to the DoJ ability to investigate and prosecute it (the current DoJ opinion, as communicated in the Mueller report, is that it can investigate and prosecute the conduct of obstruction when committed by the President, despite the fact that it cannot prosecute any crime while the accused is President, which would mean, were the DoJ to be convinced by it's investigation that the President has obstructed justice, it could prosecute him, but only after he left office.) Note particularly that the power being discussed is irrelevant to impeachment, which does not require a criminal statute as a basis. > "This is Congress's issue, not Muller's issue. But here's the evidence Muller found." It's expressly laying out why the President’s legal team’s argument that it is not a DoJ issue for criminal investigation was wrong.