8 ms·
The other part of the Long Depression that's frequently glossed over is the substitution effect. While prices in aggregate declined, some prices declined extre
by nostrademons 8y ago
The other part of the Long Depression that's frequently glossed over is the substitution effect. While prices in aggregate declined, some prices declined extremely rapidly while others (thanks to Baumol's Cost Disease) declined slowly or not at all. The resulting cost differential led to a fundamental change in the structure of society and its values.
What represents wealth in an agrarian society? Land, livestock, horses, slaves, servants, leisure time, and social connections. Many of these goods increased in price during the Gilded Age, or became impossible to obtain. No more homesteading the West, no more slave plantations, independent ranchers & farmers were driven out of business by the meatpacking & agribusiness industries, the domestic servant class largely disappeared.
But what happened, eventually, is that these definitions of wealth became marginalized in favor of ownership of new luxury goods. What represented wealth in the 1950s? Having an expensive car. Owning a house in the suburbs with electricity & running water, and a washing machine, dishwasher, and vacuum cleaner. Flying on jets. None of these even existed during the Gilded Age.
It's possible we'll see a similar resolution to the current crisis, where the expensive and un-automatable pillars of a middle-class existence - health care, education, housing - simply get marginalized as a backward remnant of a previous era, and new status symbols - perhaps control of virtual currencies, prowess in computer games, neural net uplinks, bionic implants - take their place.
- existencebox 8y agoSo while I concur with your thesis, that events like this can motivate fundamental changes in the structure of a society and its values, I'm going to nitpick the "why", as I think the context of how these changes are forced is at the heart of understanding their nature. As such, I think your enumeration isn't quite accurate. Prior definitions of wealth only became impossible to obtain if you didn't have enough money. You cite land, certain notables in our own government owe much of their empire to land (real estate.) While there certainly is a transferrance of many technological goods via progress, key pillars such as social connections and leisure time continue to be significant carriers of value, and as you say, potentially become more difficult to obtain. If health care, education, housing, become marginalized, I don't believe it's as an anachronism, but out of unavailability, and new social signifiers will inevitably emerge out of our very animal nature, but within our new price range, and not out of lack of want for "more traditional luxuries". (to cite anecdata, the number of peers who are at peace with their housing/commute/work life situations, increasing inversely corresponding to pay)