3 ms·
It lines up, I just wanted to point out that there needs to be no malicious exploitative intent, this kind of network state degradation naturally follows from t
by pas 8y ago
It lines up, I just wanted to point out that there needs to be no malicious exploitative intent, this kind of network state degradation naturally follows from the always ongoing optimization of resource allocation by actors involved in the process. And thus there is a natural priority of features when it comes to network equipment design, development, production, testing, marketing, support and eventual replacement.
And yes, crypto helps with enforcing the layers, it forces engineers to move to a different part of the solution space when it comes to doing things that used to be done with DPI/snooping/etc. (A lot of the meddleboxes were sort of rational responses, like a MITM caching proxy, DNS hijacking, captive portals, blablabla. And they were quick and dirty.)
- mindslight 8y agoI stand by the characterization of "exploitative". The point of protocols is to mediate between parties with diverging interests. The parties deploying meddle boxes are rationally trying to further their own interests, but they are doing so by stepping over the delineating line. In 2019, the idea that neighborly courtesy would preserve the line was obviously naive. Now we need to build concrete walls. And lest you think that my viewpoint is completely at odds with network administrators - elsewhere I've argued that raw unrestricted IP access will eventually come to be seen as a bug. Surveillance companies backhaul much of their collect unhindered precisely because "Internet access" is given as an all-or-nothing condition. IP is actually horrible for addressing such concerns, which is why attempts at egress firewalls devolve into idiotic "block everything but 80/443" (and then new devices respond by working over HTTPS). I think in the future, if we're lucky, the equivalent of firewalls will be based around type systems over PDUs, and embedded devices will be forced to specify exactly what they communicate. But those capabilities need to be kept at personal network edges (or even per-user) by devices' owners making them transparent (akin to installing a personal CA), with traffic over the centrally-controlled transit network remaining completely opaque.