3 ms·
The Justice Department innately cannot prosecute the President, because the President can always fire people as the case is made. (Edit: Also President can theo
by dragontamer 8y ago
The Justice Department innately cannot prosecute the President, because the President can always fire people as the case is made. (Edit: Also President can theoretically pardon himself) The Justice Department (and the Attorney General) serves at behest the President.
It is Congress's duty to prosecute the President through
impeachment proceedings. At best, Muller's report should be seen as a gathering of evidence for a potential impeachment process.
As such, it is very important for Congress to read over the details of this report, and decide if the level of Obstruction here rises to impeachment levels. (Remember: President Bill Clinton was impeached on Obstruction of Justice. It wasn't illegal to have sex with his intern, it was illegal for him to cover-up the fact).
In either case: there won't be any removal of Mr. Trump from office. Democrats control the house, but Republicans control the Senate. The impeachment of Nixon only really happened because Democrats controlled both sides. The House can technically impeach (just as Bill Clinton was technically impeached), but the (Republican controlled) Senate can just sit around and do nothing about it.
Still, its important for Congress to go through the process, even if its a foregone conclusion.
- nsxwolf 8y agoNixon wasn't impeached. We can only speculate as to the outcome if he had been.
- Zigurd 8y agoBill Clinton was impeached by the House and tried in the Senate for obstruction and lying to a grand jury. The case was too weak. It didn't work out well. I don't recall any related prosecutions or indictments. So that's a pretty big difference. Several guilty pleas. Several ongoing investigations. A couple trials coming up... I was aware enough of the news to follow Watergate. Trump's corruption looks to me to be worse than Watergate. Firing Comey and then telling McGhan to fire Mueller is a slow-motion Saturday Night Massacre by itself, and that's just scratching the surface. Nixon was never a national security threat except for being drunk off his ass.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> The Justice Department innately cannot prosecute the President, That theory is widely disputed. > It is Congress's duty to prosecute the President through impeachment proceedings. It is Congress’ duty and role to do that for all civil officers of the United States; this is not exclusive of criminal prosecution. Impeachment is a separate, not substitute, process which serves to protect the United States from the unique and special harms of wrongdoers in office. > The impeachment of Nixon only really happened because Democrats controlled both sides. The impeachment of Nixon did not, in fact, happen at all—Andrew Johnson and Clinton are the only Presidents to have been impeached—though both it and conviction likely would have (IIRC, whip counts in both houses were part of the reason for the resignation) had Nixon not resigned.
- dragontamer 8y ago> That theory is widely disputed. Fair point. But it was accepted by the Muller Report, and therefore Muller decided to not even TRY to prosecute Mr. Trump. (See the introduction of Volume II of the report). Perhaps one day, the theory will be tested. But for now, Muller didn't even want to test that theory. He moved forward assuming it was true.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> But it was accepted by the Muller Report Incorrect, or at best misleading; the Mueller report only accepted that the Office of Special Counsel was, by the terms of it's creation, bound by a pre-existing DoJ (Office of Legal Counsel) determination to that effect; that is, Mueller was not permitted to prosecute due to the existence of the OLC determination and the terms of Mueller's appointment, irrespective of the correctness of the OLC opinion as to whether DoJ had the power to prosecute.
- dragontamer 8y agoI'm not necessarily saying that Muller believes in that theory... only that he was operating under that theory within the context of the report. Perhaps my word "acceptance" was a poor choice. But I want to emphasize that Muller did not fight against that theory. Whether he was unable to, or whether he believed the theory is a separate issue. The important bit is that the Muller Report operated under the assumption that they couldn't indict a sitting President. Considering that something like 10 pages of the report looks like its dedicated to the constitutional powers of Congress (Article I vs Article II issues), it seems like the report is basically saying "This is Congress's issue, not Muller's issue. But here's the evidence Muller found."