7 ms·
Reading this sort of things is getting gradually more grating for me to read. We organise ourselves in a system where: "a world in which goods and services are
by andrepd 8y ago
Reading this sort of things is getting gradually more grating for me to read.
We organise ourselves in a system where: "a world in which goods and services are so cheap to produce that less and less capital is required for investment, and so easy to produce that less and less labour is required to produce them" is not a life-transforming utopia, but a catastrophe. The author constantly points this, points how growth in the "long stagnation" never materialised into better conditions and a better standard of living, and how that didn't change until war came.
Yet he never ceases to operate in the same system and to try to find the answers within the system. It never even crosses his thought that... perhaps the fundamental tenets of the system should be changed, or at the very least questionable. All he does is find convoluted ways of patching the a broken system from within the system.
- park77 8y agoWhat would you say are the changes that should be made then?
- andrepd 8y agoWhat I want to emphasise, is that it's not even the changes in concrete, but the fact that it is impossible to question the fundamentals right now, or to enact any kind of meaningful changes. When faced with a crisis in the system (or with its everyday problems and flaws), the answer is only to look at ways within the system that can correct that, and the possibility of deeper fundamental changes does not even cross the mind. Plain and simple, the current arrangement has attained the status of "dogma". But to answer your question, my opinion is that much of the power in our world is held undemocratically. Progress must be made to bring as much responsibility, power, property, etc, into democratic rule of the people whom that power affects. This is about as condensed a description as I can manage of my main convictions. After a certain point, that requires rethinking the fundamental structures and concepts of our society, or at list be willing to question them critically and honestly, rather than taking them as laws of nature.
- wool_gather 8y ago> Progress must be made to bring as much responsibility, power, property, etc, into democratic rule of the people whom that power affects. Agree. And as a counterpoint to your other point, physical/material safety is a prerequisite to this. Nobody has time to vote, or agitate to get the vote, if they're starving and have no place to sleep. That's why the cheap goods and services are potentially important.
- haskellandchill 8y agoor UBI type ideas which give everyone a voice, I think yang 2020 is the best chance to try out those ideas
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- lucretian 8y ago1) she 2) your criticism seems overly harsh. perhaps you should familiarize yourself with the author's other writings: http://www.coppolacomment.com/2019/04/keynes-and-death-of-capitalism.html http://www.coppolacomment.com/2019/04/keynes-and-death-of-ca...
- andrepd 8y ago>she Apologies, I can't edit the post anymore. >perhaps you should familiarize yourself with the author's other writings But I don't want to. I'm discussing this article, I never came across this author before (that I can recall).
- telesilla 8y ago>Yet he never ceases She never ceases. Frances is the feminine version of Francis. There is also a picture of her on the left. She did end with a link to revolution spurred by austerity and the rise of populism, where change is coming but my reading is that this coming revolution would lead again to war (or at least, deeper inequality).
- andrepd 8y ago>There is also a picture of her on the left. My blocker didn't load that, I think. >She did end with a link to revolution spurred by austerity and the rise of populism The quote is "revolutions don’t tend to end well", which is pretty telling and only confirms my assessment of her unwillingness to question the fundamentals or enact meaningful change (beyond supreficial "bandaids").
- ericd 8y agoHave you studied the history of revolutions? They really don't tend to end well...
- umadon 8y agoThat very much depends on who you were before the revolution!
- ericd 8y agoPeople like to think that. I highly recommend the Revolutions podcast, especially the French revolution section, to disabuse anyone of this notion. The have-nots had a very rough time during that revolution, along with the nobles.
- umadon 8y agoWell that's exactly my point. The French Revolution, like the American, was ultimately a victory for the merchant classes. Of course the nobles and peasants had a rough time, as you put it. Not all revolutions have the same character or, indeed, results.
- umadon 8y agoThis article is better than most, in that its conclusion steps outside the bizarro world of platonically ideal economics and mentions, ye gads, history and politics. But even so, it's worth nothing that the writer's paycheck depends on an imagination constrained by current arrangements. Always useful to check a bio: https://www.financialsense.com/contributors/frances-coppola https://www.financialsense.com/contributors/frances-coppola Anyway seems like there's a lot of these warnings from mainstream sources lately... and there's a commensurate rise in seemingly leftish candidates, at least in the US.
- rsync 8y ago"We organise ourselves in a system where: "a world in which goods and services are so cheap to produce that less and less capital is required for investment, and so easy to produce that less and less labour is required to produce them" is not a life-transforming utopia, but a catastrophe." I understand - and sympathize with - your reaction. However I have a suspicion that the authors stance is correct and, indeed, there is something catastrophic involved. If not due to the circumstances, then to our response to the circumstances (which, as you say, would seem to be heavenly). If, however, you place stock in the notion that (most) humans find happiness and meaning and fulfillment in completing meaningful and valuable work, I think it starts to make sense. You and I might have the personal makeup - or find ourselves in a stage of generational or familial development - to find meaning and joy in a post-scarcity, post "work", nuanced and refined existence. I like to think I do. But I can imagine not having that makeup and while I might not be able to point to "the absence of scarcity" or "not having meaningful work" as my affliction, I think without a doubt something would be afflicting me.
- jdietrich 8y agoWe can find meaningful work for everyone; we cannot necessarily find remunerative work for everyone. We have the economic capacity to provide remunerative work for everyone, but make-work is (almost by definition) not meaningful, especially when it is overtly designated as such. We probably don't have the economic capacity to provide everyone with the opportunity to find their own meaningful work and we certainly don't have the political will. Solving that conundrum is equal parts opportunity and crisis.
- kaycebasques 8y agoI don’t think your comment is particularly constructive. Radical change versus reform is an age-old debate that is not going to be solved on this forum. Your comments along the lines of “it’s impossible to even discuss the possibility of radical change” are silly... you’re doing it right now. I’m open to hearing radical ideas, but please make them more concrete. P.S. I have been in your shoes. I have literally said the exact same things as you. So I get where you’re coming from.