3 ms·
If the companies they buy end up making money, might this be an interesting alternative to taxes as a way to fund the government?
by skybrian 8y ago
If the companies they buy end up making money, might this be an interesting alternative to taxes as a way to fund the government?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- harshreality 8y agoCorporate profits come from somewhere. It would be a switch from an income tax to a (hidden) federal consumption tax. The initial money to pay for stock has to come from somewhere, and that somewhere would be more debt or traditional taxes. The federal government would control the companies (assuming it acquires majority shares), even if government employees aren't staffing them. That's socialism. Socialism/communism is bad because if given the opportunity for direct control, government can't help tinkering in business affairs to score political points, rather than because it makes the business better.
- skybrian 8y agoOther than raising the money, that doesn't seem too hard to solve. The Federal Reserve could buy index funds and be a passive investor like everyone else. I'm reminded of Matt Levine's running joke (?) about whether or not index funds are socialism.