5 ms·
I think the work case is the weakest possible. You're not owed a job, and you're certainly not owed a specific job. The reality is that vaccinations don't just
by arcticbull 8y ago
I think the work case is the weakest possible. You're not owed a job, and you're certainly not owed a specific job. The reality is that vaccinations don't just affect you. They affect people who aren't physically capable of being vaccinated (compromised immunity, allergy to vaccine, etc.). If you bring the ratio down below the herd immunity threshold, you can spread serious diseases to those not physically capable of being vaccinated and putting my existing employees at risk.
If I, as an employer, am forced to decide between hiring you, an antivaxxer, which risks killing even one of my existing employees, you're not getting the job, period. I owe them a duty of care before you. And their families too. And babies too young to immunize -- is it okay if they die?
This stems from a similar misunderstanding of liberty as the "freedom of speech applies to Twitter" argument. The first amendment protects you from legislation infringing on your free speech. It doesn't require private companies to broadcast your speech at your sole discretion. The same would be true of a hypothetical vaccination rule. Even if the government weren't able to legislate in this regard, nothing precludes any private party from refusing you food, a home or a job on the basis of your vaccination status. Being an antivaxxer isn't a protected class to the best of my knowledge.
- ghaff 8y agoNote that “anti-vaxxer” is probably a small subset of cant produce complete vaccination records. I’m not sure how acceptable a mandatory doctors exam and potentially booster shots would be to a lot of SV developers applying for a job. I don’t personally have a problem and early in my career got rejected from some jobs because of a small back problem. But can’t see it with the typical FANG applicant.
- arcticbull 8y agoNo problem, if they don't have a record, they can take another shot. IMO FAANGs are best suited, many have their own on-site clinics. If not, you can in states like California, head down to Walgreens and get one on the house without an appointment.
- CydeWeys 8y agoI got an MMR booster shot at work last week at the clinic in the Google NYC office. They also do annual flu shots using contracted out nurses (the clinic is too small for that big of a rush in a single week). None of this is mandatory though.
- ghaff 8y agoI don’t personally care. I don’t want to work for those companies but if I did and if I were missing a record I’d say fine—another booster won’t hurt. But I imagine it would be a non-trivial issue for them.
- masonic 8y agoYour argument could also be used to decline hiring carriers of HPV, HIV, HSV, or hepatitis.
- wtallis 8y agoNone of those diseases come at all close to being as easy to transmit as measles. The diseases you list pose little to no risk of transmission in an ordinary office setting.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]