4 ms·
This is the problem with looking at inequality all on it’s own. Take a population where everyone makes $20k per year. Great! It’s equal! Take another popula
by refurb 8y ago
This is the problem with looking at inequality all on it’s own.
Take a population where everyone makes $20k per year. Great! It’s equal!
Take another population where half make $30k and half make $50k. Oh no! Inequality!
I’d rather be in the 2nd population.
- ceejayoz 8y agoMaybe. The folks making $30k in the second population may now be spending a bunch more in childcare and hours more on their commutes, because they've been priced out of the city and now have travel from further away. As an example: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/08/17/business/economy/san-francisco-commute.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/08/17/business/economy/san-fran...
- epistasis 8y agoThe only way to be priced out is if the city refuses to accept more people and build enough housing for people. This is a conscious choice by power brokers in cities, to restrict housing availability and enrich homeowners and landlords and real estate speculators. Pricing people is not an inevitable consequence of population growth, it's the consequence of an older generation of haves deciding that younger and less wealthy people do not deserve housing in a city.
- ceejayoz 8y ago> The only way to be priced out is if the city refuses to accept more people and build enough housing for people. Which, given that it seems to happen pretty much everywhere, must be factored into decision making. "Wouldn't it be nice if humans didn't act like humans" is the sort of dreamy optimism that kills Communism.
- refurb 8y agoThat’s a separate problem.
- djakjxnanjak 8y agoThat’s my first instinct too, but things can get really messed up if the “haves” control the political process. What if they don’t like living near the “have-nots”, and ban the construction of multi-family housing near downtown? Now that the supply of housing is constrained, prices start going up. Suddenly, the have-nots can barely afford rent. I don’t think inequality is inherently evil, but it’s critical that we prioritize increasing the supply of all essential goods and services (housing, medical care, education) to create prosperity for everyone and prevent the have-nots from suffering. Via inequality, we can reward people for creating prosperity, but it’s important that this excess wealth only bids up the price of luxuries like yachts and art, not basic needs.
- manfredo 8y ago> That’s my first instinct too, but things can get really messed up if the “haves” control the political process. What if they don’t like living near the “have-nots”, and ban the construction of multi-family housing near downtown? Now that the supply of housing is constrained, prices start going up. Suddenly, the have-nots can barely afford rent. In my experience, the people that support these housing policies are the kind that would rather everyone have $20k instead of $30k/$50k. Opposition to building denser housing is generally more prevalent with "progressives". At least judging from my experience in San Francisco.
- djakjxnanjak 8y agoSan Francisco politics are controlled by wealthy landowners. Progressive opponents to development make a more sympathetic appeal, but it looks like a Baptist-bootlegger coalition to me.
- manfredo 8y agoIt's a bit more nuanced than that. A lot of the progressive housing obstructionists rent at a fraction of the market rate due to long term rent control (one of the more prominent anti-housing activists rents a 2 bedroom apartment for only $670 a month). Many of said residents are heavily nativist and disdain the "techies" and people from "flyover states" moving to "their city". Blatant nativism is not socially acceptable, so pursuing exclusionary policies under the guise of protecting renters makes it more palatable.
- johngalt 8y agoI agree with you, but I don't believe the 'inequality' complaint is generally about $30k vs $50k. It's a mischaracterization of their argument. The complaint tends to be about <$30k vs >$250k.