4 ms·
> If I could choose to just pay more in taxes One of the fallacies in play is buying insurance is put in one category. Whereas paying taxes for insurance is a
by Gibbon1 8y ago
> If I could choose to just pay more in taxes
One of the fallacies in play is buying insurance is put in one category. Whereas paying taxes for insurance is another. The first is 'good' because it's 'free market' and the second is 'bad' because it's the government taking your money's.
- conanbatt 8y agoWhat I don't get is why do you think paying 2k to a private insurance is any worse than 2k to the state.
- Can_Not 8y agoBecause the private insurance company is incentivized to optimize for profits and the state is incentivized to optimize for a healthy population.
- conanbatt 8y ago> the state is incentivized to optimize for a healthy population. The state is incentivized to be a political boon for politicians, not to give "healthy outcomes".
- helen___keller 8y ago>One of the fallacies in play is buying insurance is put in one category. Whereas paying taxes for insurance is another. The first is 'good' because it's 'free market' and the second is 'bad' because it's the government taking your money's. Well, I'm in favor of socialized healthcare and generally receptive to increased taxation, so that's definitely not the implication I was going for. But it is true that there doesn't need to be a categorical consideration at all. A more sound statement would be "I as a consumer am willing to pay dollars equal to twice my current premiums to get healthcare coverage while avoiding hassles while receiving routine healthcare" In truth I'm not making a blanket argument for any government-run healthcare system because alleviating my pain points necessarily depends on said system being efficient and well implemented. But I KNOW that the free market isn't suddenly going to start improving on these pain points without introduction of regulations to manage issues like competing doctor networks, confusing healthcare coding and opaque pricing, etc, and I have no trust that the free market types in congress have any interest in regulations of any kind, so I personally err on the side of socialized healthcare on this one.
- nybble41 8y ago> A more sound statement would be "I as a consumer am willing to pay dollars equal to twice my current premiums to get healthcare coverage while avoiding hassles while receiving routine healthcare" Ah, but are you willing to force everyone else pay twice as much so that you can get the health care you want? That's the real question. You said you were in favor of socialized healthcare, so I would guess the answer to that question is "yes", but let's at least be honest here—the private vs. public debate is never about how much you are willing to pay. Under a private system you're free to buy as much healthcare as you can afford. The point of socializing healthcare is making other people pay.
- helen___keller 8y ago> generally receptive to increased taxation
- nybble41 8y agoYes, that's the "making other people pay" part.
- helen___keller 8y agoRight I guess you were being rhetorical then, I'm saying I'm okay with it
- jfk13 8y ago> are you willing to force everyone else pay twice as much Comparisons to other (first-world) countries with socialized healthcare systems suggest that it shouldn't be necessary for everyone to pay twice as much. If everyone paid exactly the same amount as they currently do (in tax + insurance premiums) there should be plenty to fund a first-world-standard national health system. > you're free to buy as much healthcare as you can afford It's difficult to know what you can afford when you can't find out even an approximate price until it's over and the bill arrives.