5 ms·
> but the item will remain on the checklist in perpetuity, Why do you say this? Everytime you see a system flaw because of a missed step, you add to checklist
by gowld 8y ago
> but the item will remain on the checklist in perpetuity,
Why do you say this?
Everytime you see a system flaw because of a missed step, you add to checklist. Everytime you have a process flaw because of a uselss step, you remove from the checklist. There's no problem here, checklist maintenance can be a step in the checklist.
> ("Skins, skis, boots, .
"Spectacles, testicles, wallet, and watch!"
- ip26 8y agoA release checklist (for us) is inherently very risk-averse, as its raison d'être is to prevent a very expensive & dire catastrophe, and every item on the list is (metaphorically) "written in blood" [0]. As a result it's politically intractable to remove anything. [0]: https://medium.com/war-is-boring/u-s-navy-supercarriers-dominate-because-of-lessons-paid-for-with-blood-cb26f5509ac https://medium.com/war-is-boring/u-s-navy-supercarriers-domi...
- TomMckenny 8y agoAgreed. But items can move to other checklists. In this case the list item should become a unit test for the signing code since a unit test is essentially a check list for automated systems.
- grigjd3 8y agoWhere do you work, so that I know to avoid it? Documentation needs updating as things change.
- d1str0 8y agoSo the issue isn’t with checklists, it’s with policy.
- falsedan 8y agopolicy is just a way to record a decision-making process. Yet he issue is that getting the right information to be reasonably sure it’s safe to remove a checklist item is hard and made harder the longer ago the item was added
- dv_dt 8y agoI would say that a system too entrenched to consider removing anything, is fundamentally at risk of not being able to correctly analyze the system when adding anything to the checklist, and is itself at an increased risk to fail.
- bluGill 8y agoThe problem is it is easy to look an item and say "we no longer need this, remove it". It is much harder to be sure you are fixed all possible ways the problem could have happened. Maybe the system auto-signs the release - but does it in all cases? Is there a rare special case where the automatic process doesn't happen? Do you really know what tricks they have to pull in that branch office in India?
- dv_dt 8y agoThat's why the same consideration to adding an item needs to be put into removing an item, need to be put into reviewing if the checklist is relevant still at all. Broken down a different way, you need two systems: an automatic system so you're not reconsidering decisions that have good outcome (a checklist), and a considerate system that decides what goes into or out of the automatic system. If the considerate system is broken or just frozen, then you have a problem. How long it will take to manifest is a different question.
- eslaught 8y agoI think there's an asymmetry that you're not quite capturing here: when you add an item to the checklist, you have a specific concrete failure at hand (the process just failed, you had everyone on hand to do your root cause analysis, and you know exactly why). Later when you want to remove it, you (a) lose context because time has passed and memories are fallible and/or a different person is dealing with it, and (b) you have to have some reasonable assurance that you've covered other ways the same failure can occur. No amount of process can completely eliminate this asymmetry so at some point you're forced to make a tradeoff based on how risk averse you want to be.
- romwell 8y agoLong time ago when I was living with my parents, our family checklist was "Gas, light, water, cellphone, cat". Check that the gas stove is off (important). Lights off. No running water (after a few, um, incidents). You didn't leave your phone, did you, and make sure the cat didn't run out (he'd always try). I always wondered why "lights" were on the list, since nobody gave a damn about electricity bills. Guess for the same reason that "testicles" are in the parent comment's list :)
- barrkel 8y agoLeaving the lights on with the curtains drawn - and possibly the radio playing - is a hack to discourage break-ins. Someone seems to be home, but burglars can't actually look inside to check.
- marnett 8y agoElectric company propaganda!
- londons_explore 8y agoToo many people use that trick now. Even the 'put a light in an automatic timer' trick is common. Instead just put a sign up that says "Any unauthorized testicles entering the building will be donated to a good cause".
- alistairSH 8y agoExcept "spectacles, testicles, wallet, and watch" is the Catholic sign of the cross (face, lower torso, left chest, right chest). Nothing to do with checklists.
- romwell 8y agoI meant that "light" was on the list because it made the phrase roll off the tongue easier.
- dhimes 8y agoI've found cellphones don't need to be on the list but the charging cords do!
- swiley 8y agoI think a more modern version of that last checklist would include keys and phone.