3 ms·
Because abstracting one person's story to "mental health" is extremely dehumanizing. In fact, the article does address the topic head on: > "What (Twigg) has i
by mindslight 8y ago
Because abstracting one person's story to "mental health" is extremely dehumanizing. In fact, the article does address the topic head on:
> "What (Twigg) has is a great trait," Thompson said. "Unless you get into the workforce."
The truth is that personality traits aren't really considered disorders until they affect your ability to lead a normal life, the chief aspect being to "hold down a job".
So we lauded her when these traits helped her be exceptional in her field, but now that she's used that up and didn't pivot it into some more lasting form of wealth, she's left to the shitty support structure.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 8y agoIt not just "hold down a job". When your own family can't stand being around you, I would say that qualifies as a serious problem.
- mindslight 8y agoYes, I did acknowledge it was only one metric. There are many people who can't stand their families and/or vice versa, yet if they were characterized as mentally ill it would effectively nullify the term. So this is also subjectively condemning personality traits that are celebrated in other contexts, veiled with impartiality. And while this is a contributing factor to her actual situation (if she were on better terms with her family, that would be another support structure), that doesn't really have a bearing on what I said in the USian individualist paradigm.