3 ms·
> And if something (e.g. fracking) is important for you, you can study the literature (starting with books, including university handbooks -- not internet posts
by SketchySeaBeast 8y ago
> And if something (e.g. fracking) is important for you, you can study the literature (starting with books, including university handbooks -- not internet posts, not articles, and not mere scientific papers of random research on the matter)
Could you link some university handbooks you have found about fracking? And what makes university textbooks more authoritative than a scientific paper? The university handbook could very well have been written by a single author with a particular agenda - that's not removing bias at all.
- TeMPOraL 8y ago> And what makes university textbooks more authoritative than a scientific paper? Handbooks have broader scope, giving you overview of the field. Their job isn't to push agendas or most recent research, but to give you understanding of the basics of a field of study, and an ability to understand other, specialized sources of knowledge.
- SketchySeaBeast 8y agoSo you're telling me a broader book can't have bias? At what point do books start to have bias then? Also, how does that help us understand something like fracking on all it's axises? A geology book might tell you the fundamentals behind the hydrology, but it won't mention the possible environmental impact. You're still leaving giant gaps in your knowledge.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoNo. Every book has bias. But bias is not a binary thing, there are degrees to it, and what matters is reducing bias, not the impossible task of eliminating it. Maybe I have a bad day for literacy, because I don't know how to explain the self-evident notion that you're better off reading a textbook used to train professionals in a field than reading a single scientific paper, and you're better off reading that paper than reading a news piece.
- coldtea 8y ago>So you're telling me a broader book can't have bias? No, I'm telling you you're talking isolated stuff out of context, taking them to their extremes, and ask questions never implied in the original. E.g. "So you're telling me a broader book can't have bias?" No, he says "Handbooks have broader scope, giving you overview of the field and their job isn't to push agendas or most recent research, but to give you understanding of the basics of a field of study, and an ability to understand other, specialized sources of knowledge". He's not meaning it as an absolute ("no handbook ever had bias"), and he's not speaking about "broader books" in abstract, but in particular (as already said in our thread) university handbooks. Can university handbooks (and not just "broader books" in general) have bias? Perhaps, but they're broader in scope than a single study, there are no grant money depending on good results or "publish or perish", they are not reporting on one study's results but on aggregate conclusions from multiple studies, they need to agree with the established truths of the field in general. They have passed more filters than a mere research paper. >Also, how does that help us understand something like fracking on all it's axises? A geology book might tell you the fundamentals behind the hydrology, but it won't mention the possible environmental impact. If only there were handbooks and university 101 level treatments of fracking's environmental impact too, and not just hydrology methods. Oh, wait, ...
- coldtea 8y ago>Could you link some university handbooks you have found about fracking? That was an example, but books by university presses, or used in classes as bibliography, such as the following will do: https://mitpress.mit.edu/books/fracking-neighborhood https://mitpress.mit.edu/books/fracking-neighborhood https://cup.columbia.edu/book/the-fracking-debate/9780231184861 https://cup.columbia.edu/book/the-fracking-debate/9780231184... https://www.wiley.com/en-bw/Hydraulic+Fracturing+Operations%3A+Handbook+of+Environmental+Management+Practices-p-9781118946350 https://www.wiley.com/en-bw/Hydraulic+Fracturing+Operations%... >And what makes university textbooks more authoritative than a scientific paper? That the latter is a random research result, which needs years and years of other studies, peer critique, reproducibility tests, etc, to be considered valid. It's like each random BS research paper touted in the news, only to be found either overblown, misleading, non-reproducible, or wrong by another study later on. >The university handbook could very well have been written by a single author with a particular agenda - that's not removing bias at all. That's why I don't suggest reading just one. I say "study the literature" and propose talking to experts and affected people as well. All of which are not hard for a common person -- that cares deeply for the matter and wants to have an informed opinion as opposed "x media said that" -- to do. Let's say it can be done in a month or so. It's impossible for every subject? We don't have to care for "every subject", or adopt somebody else's stance (we haven't figured out ourselves) just to say we have one...
- SketchySeaBeast 8y agoYou're advocating for weeks if not months of effort on every subject, and then there's the burden of keeping up with the literature. I'm reading this all as "you'll never know anything, so don't bother".
- coldtea 8y ago>You're advocating for weeks if not months of effort on every subject, I've already said: "It's impossible for every subject? We don't have to care for "every subject", or adopt somebody else's stance (we haven't figured out ourselves) just to say we have one..." Besides, that's the price of having an informed opinion -- instead of being a dupe or a parrot... >I'm reading this all as "you'll never know anything, so don't bother". That's surely one interpretation. Another is, you don't have to know everything, but if you want to pretend you have an opinion on something, pay your dues...