3 ms·
>It’s utterly impossible to verify even a tiny bit of the information you rely on every day from first principle. Does it matter? If you resolve always to ACT
by hammock 8y ago
>It’s utterly impossible to verify even a tiny bit of the information you rely on every day from first principle.
Does it matter? If you resolve always to ACT from first principle, and put your trust in God, why worry about who is lying to you and who is not? Would you treat a liar with less compassion? Would you question God's plan?
- DoofusOfDeath 8y agoCan you restate your post? I'm having trouble understanding it.
- hammock 8y agoIf you believe that, in the end, good prevails over evil (which maybe you don't); if you believe that stacks of lies create a house of cards that must come down eventually; if you believe that the truth always comes out; if you believe in karma or just deserts - then, by acting out of solid principle (universal truths like being honest, loving your neighbor, forgiving your enemy, service of others) you will in the end encounter peace, prosperity and salvation - regardless of how others treat you, regardless of the cards you are dealt in life, regardless of whether information from others turns out to be good or bad. You might worry that a friend (or newspaper) is taking advantage of you. But if you allow that to make you cynical and selfish with your own actions, it won't lead to good things.
- dwaltrip 8y agoAppealing to god's alleged plan won't get you much mileage here.
- DoofusOfDeath 8y agoI find HN conversations more interesting when we don't filter by worldview.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- wool_gather 8y agoNot much of a contribution, though; it's just a string of rhetorical questions that have no relevance if you're not a believer. The follow-up comment below is from the same POV but has some substance.
- dwaltrip 8y agoMy comment stems from a desire for something better. I know the power of religion, belief, and a community with a shared worldview. I was raised religiously. However the major belief systems on offer today are stunted with so much baggage (e.g. wild claims of the supernatural, conflict with science, outdated morals, etc.) that they don't work for a growing number of people. As long as there are great unknowns in the universe and in life, which I think there will always be, then there will be an important role for some form of spirituality. And ethics will always be important as well. We need something better than the major religions of today. They are insufficient. They are not what they claim. In my own life, having been unable to take on the belief system of my parents, the best thing I've found so far is meditation of the breath along with a dash of Buddhist ethics and philosophy. Of course, I have kept many of the moral teachings from my upbringing, which I appreciate. But it's not the same. There's more to say, but I don't yet have all of the words. I want better, and if I can tactfully push others to help me find a new way, then I'll try to do so. I realize my initial comment probably didn't do this very well. Perhaps this isn't even the right venue. Much to think about.
- ThrowawayR2 8y ago> If you resolve always to ACT from first principle, and put your trust in God, why worry about who is lying to you and who is not? Reminds me of the old joke about the man of great faith who was trapped in a flood: https://storiesforpreaching.com/i-sent-you-a-rowboat/ https://storiesforpreaching.com/i-sent-you-a-rowboat/. I think I am safe in opining that even most clergy would describe such a policy as sticking one's head in the sand rather than being true to one's faith.