4 ms·

No, I didn't specifically want "Minority Report". I clarified that immediately in my first followup. And it's ok if you don't see the value in a gesture UI. I

• teddyh 8y ago
  > I clarified that immediately in my first followup. Where? I don’t see it. On the contrary, you doubled down by saying “Jarvis”, and gave a link, which, as I said previously, is exactly the same style of interface as in Minority Report, and has the same problem. You also said that you thought that the Soli technology could make the Minority Report interface “achievable”. Later, when we were discussing the Soli interface specifically, you said “I’m only moving my hands. I can still move my hands while resting my arms.”, but you never said that Soli is what you wanted. So if you, contrary to what you originally wrote, don’t want Minority Report and/or Jarvis, what do you want? Soli? That style might possibly work, but I remain skeptical; I would have to be convinced that Soli does not suffer from the gorilla arm problem, since nothing in the Soli demo video seem to show a comfortable mode of working for extended periods, only spiffy short-term interactions.
  • melling 8y ago
    My very next response when I mentioned Google Soli: """ Sure. That was almost 2 decades ago. We've given it some more thought. https://atap.google.com/soli/ https://atap.google.com/soli/ """ I'm asking for a good gesture UI, or at least a good start that can evolve as we learn. I'm not asking for a specific implementation.