3 ms·
> The question that people actually care about is whether the AI can be strategically better. We already know the answer to that; computers dominate humans str
by roenxi 8y ago
> The question that people actually care about is whether the AI can be strategically better.
We already know the answer to that; computers dominate humans strategically. There are two types of strategic decisions - those made using maths, and those made by guessing. Computers are perfectly capable of doing both, and better at at least one. Besides, Go is far more strategic than DotA and computers are better than us at Go.
The reason we are seeing research in videogames is purely tactical. Historically computers couldn't compete tactically with humans because there were too many variables and decisions to write up an if-then loop that made sense. DotA is 95% a game of mechanical domination, 5% strategic concerns. The strategic concerns could be modelled with some pretty basic Bayesian models and probably be world class; it is item-hero combinations, a few rules about location on the map and guesswork.
All the challenge is taking that strategy then implementing it mechanically - doing all the stuff OpenAI 5 is demonstrating regarding jukes, tactical positioning, spell timings and judging relative strength with incomplete information.
DotA isn't as fast as it looks either, it is quite a slow game in terms of reflexes. Reflexes tip close games, but positioning tips the average game. OG was losing because computers are just better at estimating margins of safety.