4 ms·
Based on the discussion from the Cloudflare announcement and here, I don't think people understand why Amp was created and is being heavily pushed by Google: gl
by judge2020 8y ago
Based on the discussion from the Cloudflare announcement and here, I don't think people understand why Amp was created and is being heavily pushed by Google: global accessibility.
Many countries, including India, are just now getting widespread broadband rollout. Due to its infancy, many ISPs have data caps and may even be delivering data over 4G/LTE to homes. With AMP, Google and CF have the privilege of driving all of this (search-driven) bandwidth to datacenters within the same country, or at least the same continent, to the visitor. If all of this content was really served from the origin, latency would be considerably worse since the data will have to go through the undersea cables and the performance issues that may occur with bad routing.
You could also say the Data Saver web proxy they run is to encourage these users to browse the web without worrying as much about their phone data bill.
Google really wants everyone in these countries to be using and depending on the Internet just as much as Americans use and depend on it, otherwise they may miss out on advertising $$$ potential from a country that's ~4.5 times more populated than the United States.
- chrischen 8y agoPeople in India aren't as interested in your average Western news site as you (presumably from the West) are.
- judge2020 8y agoFair. At this point, the focus has probably shifted from that since these ISPs and cell providers aren't as technically limited as the United States was 10-15 years ago. I feel like AMP started out this way at the core, "How can we ensure these web pages load fast and aren't eating up these users' data plans?", but then the dreaded parts of AMP like search rank preference, Google being the one in the URL bar, etc. were afterthoughts that were put in to make AMP widely adopted and to increase their stranglehold on the Internet as a whole.
- 48309248302 8y agoThat isn't a main reason. People are going to use the internet either way. Google is making a power grab by breaking web standards (embrace, extend, extinguish), and companies like Cloudflare are enabling them. Mozilla has marked Signed HTTP Exchanges as harmful.
- SquareWheel 8y agoI'm sorry but if you believe AMP breaks web standards, then you do not understand AMP. It is built entirely from the ground up on web standards.
- 48309248302 8y agoSigned HTTP Exchanges? https://mozilla.github.io/standards-positions/ https://mozilla.github.io/standards-positions/
- SquareWheel 8y agoYes, that's a standard signed by the IETF. It's also an incredibly new feature (supported by AMP starting today).
- TeMPOraL 8y agoIt's not an actual standard if it's forced on everyone by a single vendor abusing its market dominance.
- Kiro 8y agoYou're completely exaggerating. Please educate yourself by reading the full conversation leading up to the "harmful" tag before spamming that link again: https://github.com/mozilla/standards-positions/issues/29 https://github.com/mozilla/standards-positions/issues/29
- 48309248302 8y agoThe point there is that is it not supported by Mozilla. Google has strong-armed publishers into implementing their websites in a restricted Google format that speeds up websites just for Google Chrome and Google Chromium-based browsers. It's an unethical power grab by Google on multiple levels.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- larkeith 8y agoWhile I disagree that this is the primary reason for Google pushing AMP (if it were, carousels would be page size and speed limited, possibly taking into consideration CDN availability, not (Google-)AMP-exclusive), it is definitely a facet of the argument that's been underappreciated.
- JohnFen 8y ago> I don't think people understand why Amp was created and is being heavily pushed by Google: global accessibility. I think people understand this. The issue is that AMP is forced on people who don't want it. I have no problem with AMP being provided for people who do. A method of opting out would resolve this.