8 ms·
The Moral Order of Panera
- int_19h 8y agoIt seems to me that the author misunderstands the nature of the libertarian moral-economic approach. The whole point of it is that whatever decisions people make wrt charity and welfare with their own money are the only ones that reflect their true morality, and thus, a free market will simply express the moral consensus of the society in which it operates. Thus, if the experiment supports the theory that "consumers don’t prefer conscious capitalist businesses", from that perspective, it is not a failure - it just means that the current consensus is that the various social causes aren't important enough to pay for them. That is also why people who subscribe to this value system wouldn't talk about SNAP - from their perspective, it's some people deciding what to do with other people's money, which cannot be moral by definition. You may disagree with that value system and its definitions - I do - but you have to at least acknowledge that it is different enough that what you see as problems is not necessarily what its adherents see as problems. In this case, the article writer is complaining at the end that it's a failed attempt at "solution to a problem we already know how to solve" - but is it really meant to solve that problem? I don't think so.
- brianberns 8y ago> the current consensus is that the various social causes aren't important enough to pay for them No, the only consensus I see from this article is that this particular approach to solving a very important social problem doesn't work.
- int_19h 8y agoLike I said, I do not agree with libertarian ethics. I'm explaining how it looks from that perspective. And in it, by definition, whatever the market does is the consensus. The larger point is that they're not trying to solve the problem you (and the author) think about. It's not about solving hunger per se. It's about alleviating it to the extent permissible by the bounds of what their value system deems moral - and those bounds do not accommodate wealth redistribution via taxation. So it's kinda like complaining that communists can't solve the problem of protecting private property - well, yes, but they aren't trying to, so you should complain about that very fundamental premise. In a way, it is rather like religion. Islamic banking, for example, is hardly efficient at solving most problems that modern banking does. If all you cared about was solving them, you wouldn't need it. But if you are under a religious prohibition on charging interest, then you have to come up with all those alternative convoluted schemes, that don't cover many scenarios outright, and are inefficient in others - but it's the best that can be had. Conversely, if a problem requires a sinful action to solve, then it's not really a problem. "Whatever God does is good" is a common religious trope - replace it with "whatever the market does is good", and you'll see that it works just the same here.
- inflatableDodo 8y ago>The whole point of it is that whatever decisions people make wrt charity and welfare with their own money are the only ones that reflect their true morality, and thus, a free market will simply express the moral consensus of the society in which it operates. Alternatively, emergent effects from the complex structure of the network come to dominate over the moral choices of the nodes and so therefore it acts more like weather than any actual reflection of a societal consensus, with the overall climate being driven by those who have inherited the most currency.
- Lowkeyloki 8y agoYou can't apply what you describe as a "libertarian moral-economic approach" to a capitalist culture and society and claim that the result reflects the true moral fiber of its citizens. The system is too complex to make such a sweeping generalization. For example, I could probably stand to donate far more money to charities and causes than I do. The reason I don't give more is because I worry about whether the charity I choose is being run efficiently, and I worry about my own financial stability changing the moment I give the money away, and a million other varyingly logical/illogical concerns. I'm sure I'm not the only one who fits this description. Not to mention the capitalist fiction of being able to pull oneself up by one's bootstraps as an excuse for why I deserve the money I've made and the less fortunate are simply lazier, etc. I personally no longer believe in that, but a lot of people do. So-called "hustle culture" is somewhat related in that it romanticises having to work non-stop to be financially secure. But I digress, as I've wandered off topic. My point is that it's unfair to judge a society's morality by the measure you've applied due to all of these factors of capitalism and more.
- jrochkind1 8y agoBy that logic, it is moral to let people starve to death when you have enough not to. I guess some people might think that.
- panarky 8y agoWe all collectively benefit when children get a good education, when everyone has fast and safe transportation, when everyone has enough nutritious food, and when healthcare is available to all. These collective goods must be paid for collectively, or the free-rider problem guarantees failure. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free-rider_problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free-rider_problem I will gladly pay my share to secure these social goods, but I won't shoulder the entire burden by myself. When I see most people free riding, I'm much less likely to step up and be the chump who contributes.
- TimTheTinker 8y ago> These collective goods must be paid for collectively, or the free-rider problem guarantees failure. That’s close to the truth, but it ignores the efficacy of charities and churches — where many people can (and do) give generously to help others. When run well, those do far more good than even government programs. I challenge anyone who cares about the poor and wants to make a big difference to give to, volunteer at, or even start one of these nonprofit community programs. In my city there’s a charity that provides clothes to poor people at massive discounts. They don’t feel like they’re getting a handout, since they’re still paying (less than $1 per item) - hence they don’t lose any sense of dignity or “providing for their family”. It also reduces free-loading since you do have to pay. And store employees take time to help people with all sorts of things - job applications, government forms. If I’m bit mistaken, they also offer counseling, showers, and a cold weather shelter.
- Mediterraneo10 8y agoThe thing is, charities and churches are rarely "run well". Many charities have become a cash cow for their executives and office staff (“Hey, look, we can direct a lot of these donations to paying us extremely generous salaries”), with actual generosity to those in need almost seeming an afterthought. I saw this firsthand when I volunteered in the central office of a charity, and it rather shattered my idealism. Churches have been notorious for either stipulating that recipients act in a certain church-approved way to get aid, or giving charity in the hope that recipients will convert. Either way, it hardly strikes most people outside that religion as "generous". It is worth pointing to the Nordic countries, where private charitable endeavours have largely faded away with the rise of the welfare state, and even the local churches are happy to let the state take care of the feeding, clothing and housing business because the state enjoys economy of scale far beyond any church’s ability. In spite of the dwindling of private charity, those countries have less wealth disparity than countries fond of charitable activity. Consequently, some feel that charity is a just an awkward substitute for a functional state, not a good thing in itself.
- tunesmith 8y agoIt sounds like the problems are mostly shame and self-selection, which could perhaps be iterated on, for instance with some sort of automatic dynamic pricing. For instance, it's a lousy first idea, but I wonder if credit card terminals can tell how close you are to your credit limit, and if you're close it'll automatically adjust your price downward.
- rossdavidh 8y agoSo, I can totally believe that this particular idea didn't work well. I can totally agree that we should learn from it, perhaps that people want to give $ to feed the poor only when they don't have to sit next to them, or that people on lunch break don't want to have to tackle a moral quandary just then. But, the article seemed needlessly negative. So, the CEO of Panera tried something, put his business experience to work seeing if this idea would succeed, and when it didn't, after giving it a fair shot, he shut it down. I don't think that's a reason to hate on him for trying it, or that anyone who thought it was worth a try should have known better. Just a reason for solving hunger in a different way (perhaps the simpler one of just giving food-insecure people some lunch money).
- cooper12 8y agoThe reason it's so negative is because it already notes that prior research showed consumer responsibilization doesn't work. Shaich might see himself as good-minded, even volunteering as cashier, but he comes off more as misguided (what with his Ted Talk enthusiasm) and out of touch (note the vast gap between the customers and this man who made $2 million that year). I'm not sure why you expected some bland analytical article. The author clearly doesn't agree with Libertarian ideals or conscious capitalism.
- jonas21 8y agoThe only research this article cites is a 2017 study that looked at Panera Cares itself. You can hardly fault the Panera CEO for trying when his efforts are what allowed the research to be done in the first place.
- cooper12 8y agoOkay I was incorrect on that front, [0] but the field of economics isn't exactly new, nor is the general idea itself (things like pay-what-you-want, voluntary contributions, etc). [0]: Here's the paper: https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/2051570714540560 https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/205157071454056...
- 8y ago
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- tareqak 8y agoI found the employee who said the discount was only available the first time to be a symptom of a self-defeating policy: once you make such a statement, the transaction would become uncomfortably personal as illustrated by the account of the mother in the article. Having a sign outside the store and another one near the checkout would be less personal. The most that I would ask an employee to say in that sort of situation is "Please pay it forward when you can". The part about the customer dress code was declared to be unevenly enforced between the Panera Cares store and the normal Panera bread store, so that seems like another issue of policy. The Yelp comment that mentioned smell is a tough one. I was thinking about not having any place to sit period to avoid that, but then one could make the argument that isn't the Panera Bread experiment. I applaud Ron Shaich for at least trying. I personally would not have gone towards opening four stores without proving out and refining the first experience of the first one. By just having this one store, it could have stayed open longer before closing, and the employees working at that store could have been given better job security e.g. if this store doesn't work out, then I'll guarantee you a position of employment at your nearest Panera Bread.
- nateabele 8y agoAgree with many other commenters here that holding this up as a supposed failure of free-market libertarianism borders on absurdity. Cut against the grain of human nature and you're going to fail, irrespective of your philosophy. Also, counterpoint: https://www.philly.com/philly/entertainment/television/Rosas-Pizza-gets-surprise-from-Ellen-DeGeneres.html https://www.philly.com/philly/entertainment/television/Rosas...
- Fellshard 8y agoThere's a secondary cause mixed in here I'd like to propose. If you were to pay forward at this Panera, you don't know where your money is going to. That alone would make you hesitate as a consumer: You're not sure whether you'll be paying forward for someone who is in extensive need of the meal, or just a well-off customer who's looking for their discount-of-the-week for a decent sandwich. It's the same kind of unease that pushes people away from giving money to panhandlers: they want to know that they are actually helping a person survive, not enabling them to seek out the means that may have contributed. (No, that's not what all of them will do. The point is you don't have the information and you will tend to err on the safe side in that context.)
- js2 8y agoFWIW, Raleigh has had an independent non-profit pay-what-you-can restaurant for about 16 months now: https://tableraleigh.org/about https://tableraleigh.org/about Customers have multiple options to pay and to pay-it-forward. - Pay the suggested price - At least half of the suggested price - By volunteering with us Pay it Forward - Tip to fulfill our mission - Buy a $10 token to hand out yourself in the community I suspect these may work better as independent establishments as opposed to being part of a chain or large corporation.
- askvictor 8y agoMelbourne, Australia has had a pay-what-you-can restaurant (actually a number of them coming and going) since 2000: https://www.lentilasanything.com https://www.lentilasanything.com
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- maxxxxx 8y ago“I suspect these may work better as independent establishments as opposed to being part of a chain or large corporation” Agreed. I am always skeptical of large corporations doing charity work. It’s never clear clear where the money is going and whether they just do it for PR. I find it easier to trust smaller organize.
- shiftoutbox 8y agoYou spelled Pantera wrong Pantera was an American heavy metal band from Arlington, Texas. The group was formed in 1981 by the Abbott brothers – drummer Vinnie Paul and guitarist Dimebag Darrell – along with lead vocalist Terry Glaze.
- nvssj 8y agoIt's completely impossible for an idea like this to work in a country with such a high % of black population.
- jkingsbery 8y ago> If he did, he may have had to admit that Panera Cares was nothing but an elaborate branding exercise, a solution to a problem we already know how to solve. I would expect there to be a lot less food insecurity if we actually knew how to solve it.
- humanrebar 8y agoYeah, I would consider "get everyone to agree with me on topic X" to be a very unsolved problem.