4 ms·
Some interesting bits to counter the title's face value: > Researchers followed thousands of BJ’s Wholesale Club employees for a year > Nearly all the studies
by hombre_fatal 8y ago
Some interesting bits to counter the title's face value:
> Researchers followed thousands of BJ’s Wholesale Club employees for a year
> Nearly all the studies to date had been observational and have largely concluded that the programs save some money for employers. But this study randomly assigned employees to a wellness program and compared their results with those of employees who were not enrolled in such efforts.
> Employers looking for a quick reduction in their health care spending will be disappointed
It makes sense to me that benefits come on a longer time scale and when employees join the specific programs that interest/apply to them (rather than random assignment).
- mirimir 8y agoYes. Following people for just a year is ~meaningless. If someone quits smoking, for example, the benefit of reduced lung cancer incidence will show up on decade scale.
- jnwatson 8y agoI’m sure the biggest intervention they are hoping for is weight loss. The reduction in insulin/metformin prescriptions would be evident if the program was effective.
- tomjen3 8y agoIf they need to lose 30-40 pounds (or more) that might not happen in the 1 year time frame. And don't bother replying and telling me you lost that much weight in less time, I am aware that can be done, but not by small tweaks which these incentives normally give.
- 0xcde4c3db 8y ago> when employees join the specific programs that interest/apply to them (rather than random assignment) The problem with this from a study standpoint is that it introduces self-selection bias. A complication for exercise programs in particular is that avoidance of exercise can be caused by cardiovascular and metabolic dysfunction.