5 ms·
I kinda agree. 4G feels "fast enough" to me, just like PCs have become pretty much "fast enough" about a decade ago. I'd rather see more work put into usabilit
by mcv 8y ago
I kinda agree. 4G feels "fast enough" to me, just like PCs have become pretty much "fast enough" about a decade ago.
I'd rather see more work put into usability than in even higher speeds.
- jethro_tell 8y agoThe funny thing with the internet is that the content really doesn't ntake up that much space/speed. It's the ads and trackers. So that's why the industry is lobbying for that. Also, We still haven't even hit theoretical 3g speeds. But reallocation of spectrum is a quick easy way to get there without doing the work.
- frandroid 8y ago> the content really doesn't ntake up that much space/speed video streaming
- slang800 8y ago> Entertainment doesn't count.
- arcticbull 8y agoI feel like they answered their own question, entertainment does count.
- yellowapple 8y agoNot all video streaming is for entertainment. Case in point: security cameras.
- zrm 8y agoOn the other hand, discouraging wireless security cameras is a benefit because they have poor security properties. Wireless exposes the cameras to attack by anyone within wireless range rather than requiring the attacker to have physical access, and also allows an attacker to disable the cameras with a wireless jammer.
- yellowapple 8y agoThey do indeed have poor security properties, but sometimes it's the only viable option. For example, you might need to setup a camera in some outdoor spot that's too far for a wired connection to be practical (Ethernet only runs so far, and I ain't aware of very many cameras that use fiber), in which case a wireless connection and a solar panel might very well be the way you'd have to go. Also, wired connections (especially outdoor ones) have a tendency to be vulnerable to things like wire cutters or fiber-seeking backhoes. I'd imagine a competent security system implementer would find some way to physically secure the cable as best as possible, but given that a wireless jammer is a much more sophisticated attack strategy than, say, some snips or an "accidental" strike by some piece of equipment, going wireless might be a viable tradeoff.
- zrm 8y ago> For example, you might need to setup a camera in some outdoor spot that's too far for a wired connection to be practical (Ethernet only runs so far, and I ain't aware of very many cameras that use fiber), in which case a wireless connection and a solar panel might very well be the way you'd have to go. Cameras that use fiber exist, but you could also just use an ethernet camera and a fiber to ethernet converter. > Also, wired connections (especially outdoor ones) have a tendency to be vulnerable to things like wire cutters or fiber-seeking backhoes. I once encountered a survivalist who would always carry a length of fiber optic cable with him, that way if he was ever hopelessly lost in the wilderness he needed only to bury the fiber and a backhoe would be along promptly to dig it up. One solution in those cases is to use directional wireless, which is harder to jam, but then you're back to not needing 5G. If it's important enough you can also attach a storage device directly to the camera so that if there is a temporary network interruption the data isn't lost. Of course, you also have the trouble that the cameras themselves tend to be vulnerable to things like rocks. Securing something which is out in the open is hard. > given that a wireless jammer is a much more sophisticated attack strategy than, say, some snips or an "accidental" strike by some piece of equipment Jamming wireless is not really that sophisticated. It's both easy an inexpensive to do it. The main impediment is that the legal penalties can be rather severe, but criminals are not well known for their fastidious adherence to the law.
- gsich 8y agoIt's also every useless TCP connection because stupid site providers chose to load stuff from Google instead of the page they currently have the connection open. Easily adds 3 RTT, maybe even an additional 4 if you use TLS.
- brianpgordon 8y agoIt's pretty expensive though. I pay $10/GB (marginal) for Google Fi. That doesn't really scale to streaming HD video. I imagine a roomier higher-frequency spectrum would help get contention down and lower costs.
- ArlenBales 8y agoGoogle Fi is the exception, not the rule. You can get "unlimited data" LTE for $60+ with other carriers. (e.g. T-Mobile One is $70 for a single line) Google Fi is for people who mostly use wi-fi. (I use Google Fi)
- bri3d 8y agoProject Fi is a little more expensive but can be used as an unlimited plan at $80/mo for a single line, as they stop charging for data after 6GB.
- brianpgordon 8y ago"Unlimited" plans just hope that not too many people use a lot of data. But if you're really one of the people who doesn't use much data, you might as well use a plan which charges per gigabyte, and then you're exposed to the real per-gigabyte cost. Market forces therefore keep the cost of unlimited plans roughly in line, and the per-gigabyte cost is still relevant even for unlimited plans.
- sneak 8y agohttps://www.t-mobile.com/offers/mydatausage https://www.t-mobile.com/offers/mydatausage T-Mobile is “unlimited data” until 50GB, then they limit your speed.
- mcv 8y ago50GB is pretty generous. Not truly unlimited, but I could definitely live with that.
- 8y ago
- jopsen 8y agoWe need to advance all parameters of our technology stack.. changes are incremental and take time, it'll be many years before 5G is widely available. 5G as I've understood it also more about latency.