5 ms·
The fact that a 100% of the think-tanks taking corporate funding (from the likes of Microsoft, Amazon, Twitter, Facebook, Google, Airbnb, Uber, Verizon, eBay) a
by ignoramous 8y ago
The fact that a 100% of the think-tanks taking corporate funding (from the likes of Microsoft, Amazon, Twitter, Facebook, Google, Airbnb, Uber, Verizon, eBay) are trying to undermine excellent privacy laws passed by California [0] and Illinois state assemblies should come as a surprise to no one.
The problem is these think-tanks or variants thereof might end up representing the tech industry in most places where it matters anyway, just like how most of the standard bodies have been taken over by them and now slowly approve of features that further their business motives (I am looking at you ITU).
Two ways (there must be more?) I can think of to fix the behaviour of these behemoths:
1. External: Internet Activism. This has been well underway for a long time now but the corporates are patient beasts. The problem always remains gathering enough support [1] and generally the short attention span of the larger populace.
2. Internal: The employees. Be critical, put yourselves in akward situations, start demanding answers [2]. The problem might be risking job security? That could be offset by forming a large enough group?
--
[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17420849 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17420849
[1] Btw, the signees of this letter care about your privacy: https://www.eff.org/document/december-2018-preemption-letter https://www.eff.org/document/december-2018-preemption-letter
[2] https://demandprogress.org https://demandprogress.org
/offtopic https://firstlook.media https://firstlook.media is doing a great job. Almost all their articles are of high quality.
- 4ntonius8lock 8y agoIs there any law/legal mechanism which could put automatic expiration on new laws? Is there anything I could suggest to my lawmakers for this to happen? I mean, we seem to be following a pattern: Big power wants something that directly and negatively impact the quality of life of the majority of the populace. Populace rises up against this. Big power 'loses'. Big power makes the push again next year. People rise up, but a little less. Big power 'loses'. Repeat until popular power is worn out and big power gets what they want. Once passed, popular outrage won't remove it, it's way harder to get support for repealing than for approving. So... I'd like to support something that changes that system from working that way. I'd think an expiration date would due... but I'm open to supporting anything that would break this pattern.
- ace_of_spades 8y agoI have had similar ideas and would love to propose something even more radical. Treat laws like theories and model the expected/desired effects that a law should have at certain time points/intervals. If the observed outcomes diverge too much from the intended outcomes there would need to be an automatic review of that legislation. There are obviously huge challenges associated with this as we are living in a dynamic world but I would love to see a push towards more evidence based politics and more rational discussions around the often implicit assumptions underlying specific legislation. INAL and maybe there is something like this going on internally in politics but I think there is more to be done in making this accessible to the public and giving it more room in political discussions.
- heavenlyblue 8y agoDemocratically speaking, the only reason Big Power wins is due to the fact that it's incredibly inefficient to stand behind interests of many parties investing small amounts against single players investing huge amounts. One would think we need interest groups more.
- luckylion 8y ago> One would think we need interest groups more. Would love to see more of those, especially in the EU, and the way they have them in the US. I'd love a privacy focused action group, but I don't want to buy a host of unrelated political issues with that. The EFF and similar organisations do a pretty good job at that, would love if we had more groups like that over here.
- AWildC182 8y agoI love the idea, especially as a way of un-bundling beliefs so we're not all beholden to one of two massive and far reaching belief systems. That said, I worry that it's too easy for small advocacy groups to get steamrolled by bigger interests if they prove to be a problem. Even if they're popular with the public, it just takes a payment to a PR firm of your choice to roll a story that they're selling dead babies and suddenly everyone is confused.
- AWildC182 8y agoI'm curious, would you mind expanding on the ITU thing? Is this a 5G band allocation issue or something?
- rexpop 8y ago> The problem might be risking job security? That could be offset by forming a large enough group? You're talking about workplace organizing to mitigate reprisal risk when taking direct action, aka "sabotage". The IWW has literature on how to engage in such endeavors, and a good relationship with the TWC, who're organizing the tech industry in such a manner. Please note I've so far omitted the word "union", although it's a concept adjacent to what you're reaching for. 1. https://www.iww.org/PDF/Official/IWW_organizing_manual.pdf https://www.iww.org/PDF/Official/IWW_organizing_manual.pdf 2. https://techworkerscoalition.org https://techworkerscoalition.org