3 ms·
I think it'd be hard to directly compare statistics, because the timeframes and mechanics are a lot different. Startup success, for some definition of success,
by _delirium 16y ago
I think it'd be hard to directly compare statistics, because the timeframes and mechanics are a lot different.
Startup success, for some definition of success, tends to happen or not happen within five years or so; while the hurdles to become a tenured professor at a top research university are much more spaced out. Typically, it's 5-8 years of grad school, possibly 1-3 years of a postdoc, and 6-7 years being untenured faculty. At any one stage, the odds in academia are not that bad; for example, if you're an untenured Stanford prof, your chances of becoming a tenured prof are actually quite good. But you have to make it through the whole 15-20-year process to get there.
As a result, startups also have more iterability: if a startup fails, you can plausibly try a second, or a third, perhaps taking totally different approaches each time. You can't really do that with an academic career path, since the time needed to get through the process and build a reputation makes it nearly impossible to decide, "well, going for a CS faculty position at CMU didn't work, maybe I'll go back to grad school and try for a philosophy professorship at Oxford this time".
On the other hand, since it's a whole career rather than a single venture, it's less clear what "success" or "failure" is for an academic career, unless you really have your heart set on a very specific goal. For example, if you end up not being able to get the tenured position you want, but do end up working at a research lab in industry doing interesting stuff, is that a success or failure? With startups it's usually clearer that either it's in business or it isn't after five years.