3 ms·
Buildings of this age are better thought as palimpsests, mutable structures repurposed over generations. The building survived wars, revolutions, renovations a
by gumby 8y ago
Buildings of this age are better thought as palimpsests, mutable structures repurposed over generations. The building survived wars, revolutions, renovations and neglect. The spire that toppled was itself a modern addition that after a century is now mourned as canonical.
The building will be restored and revised and will be beloved again. Some will complain it's not the same, some will swear it's as good as it was and some will celebrate "improvements." I just hope the acoustics survive, though IMHO there are other, smaller churches that sounds better.
There's plenty of hideous stuff in Paris as well but I won't name names because what I consider dreadful some celebrate -- and perhaps we're both right.
(former Paris resident, though I wouldn't call myself a "Parisian")
- gregoriol 8y agoLet's hope they don't "improve" it with an Apple store inside.
- SiempreViernes 8y agoI'm sure the mere suggestion has put you on some French watchlist.
- pvaldes 8y agoIf apple can design a new super-thin futuristic tower that would optically dissapear at some moments when you walk around it I would consider their savoir-faire at least.
- gumby 8y agoThat would be perfectly consistent with some earlier uses of the building. Despite the story of jesus booting the money changers from the temple, for centuries big cathedrals like nddp were large general-use public resources, typically one of the only major building for miles. As it happens nddp was built with some other palaces already there (e.g. pieces of what became the louvre) or contemporaneously under construction (e.g. Sainte Chapelle). But still it almost certainly housed businesses among other activities over the centuries.
- ihuman 8y agoLike DC's Carnegie Library?