4 ms·
> The only point in taxing corporations vs. people directly is I disagree, you're skipping a huge governmental benefit that almost all the biggest corporations
by Terr_ 8y ago
> The only point in taxing corporations vs. people directly is
I disagree, you're skipping a huge governmental benefit that almost all the biggest corporations request/receive: "Limited Liability."
If Nuclear Asbestos Infant Toys goes bankrupt, everybody else is picking up the tab for land-cleanup and tumor-removal.
In other words, those owners have chosen to socialize their company's risks, so it's only natural and fair for some of the company's profits to be socialized at the same junction.
- thrill 8y agoThe smallest corporation receives that same benefit.
- Terr_ 8y agoUh... okay? My point was that commonplace/large/consequential portions of the nation's economic activity occurs in the context of limited-liability.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 8y agoI dunno if that's very different. Personal risks are socialized too -- via a mechanism known as bankruptcy. Anyway, again, it's a question of who you're targeting. If you think limited liability specifically is something that ought to incur a tax of that amount, then, sure, tax them that amount. But then company owners ought to be able to drop the limited liability feature and receive a lesser tax burden, right? I'm suspect Apple's owners would be happy with that trade. Unlimited liability in exchange for a zero percent tax rate? Bring it on. What, realistically, is the most damage that a computer is going to cause? The damages from patent infringement are often limited by the economic harm, which is at any rate likely to be far less than profits. Not to put words in your mouth, but if I had to guess you would not be willing to offer companies this out. I think that should make you question whether limited liability, specifically, is why companies should be taxed.
- int_19h 8y agoNot OP, I'd be perfectly fine with a tax specifically on limited liability, and I think you vastly underestimate the value of that arrangement to the company owners.
- 1ta 8y agoLimited Liability protects shareholders from the company's creditors. It says nothing about regulatory consequences. Nor a regulation treat a incorporated and unincorporated entity differently. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Limited_liability https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Limited_liability