3 ms·
I feel like this is another instance of "useful feature gets removed because of security vulturism[1]" --- something which has been happening for a while, but h
by userbinator 8y ago
I feel like this is another instance of "useful feature gets removed because of security vulturism[1]" --- something which has been happening for a while, but has gotten infuriatingly frequent lately. In this case, the mere fact that you're using a third-party list already suggests trust of the author, or at least an implicit acknowledgement that your ideas of what should be filtered agree.
Ad blocking extensions should consider dropping support for the $rewrite filter option. It’s always possible to abuse the feature to some degree, even if only images or style sheets are allowed to be redirected.
The classic "ban it because it can be abused" mindset. Let's ban the use of computers too, certainly that would be more secure!
Google has been notified about the exploit, but the report was closed as “Intended Behavior”, since they consider the potential security issue to be present solely in the mentioned browser extensions.
As they should, because what user-agents are doing have nothing whatsoever to do with their site.
(Disclaimer: I don't use ABP nor uBlock nor any in-browser blocking extensions, so I have no conflicts of interest here. I use a full MITM proxy which is far more powerful than anything you can do with a browser extension. I wonder what he'll think about that...)
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19660677 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19660677
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Forge36 8y agoIt could have been implemented in a more restrictive way to prevent this issue and allow more targeted behaviors, instead it allows third party lists (which already require a users trust) to run code. Previously this wasn't the case. Can your MITM proxy modify HTTPS traffic? If so, how did you configure your machines to trust the cert you're using?
- userbinator 8y agoCan your MITM proxy modify HTTPS traffic? If so, how did you configure your machines to trust the cert you're using? Yes, of course. It wouldn't be very useful otherwise. The proxy has its own CA, and I install the cert into the trusted roots of all the machines I use.