3 ms·
Can’t we just say “your profit for the purposes of taxation is the profit you report to shareholders?”
by olliej 8y ago
Can’t we just say “your profit for the purposes of taxation is the profit you report to shareholders?”
- rb808 8y agoYeah I think this is the real problem. Most people think Amazon makes a lot of money. They even say they made $12B, but they gave billions to of RSUs to employees so the IRS wisely says they didn't make much. The truth is they didn't make much/any money which is why their tax is low.
- olliej 8y agoThe problem I have is being able to report different profits to different groups - you should be required to have a single pretax profit number, and that is what you report. If you really don’t make money then you should be required to report that to your shareholders, and conversely if you tell your shareholders you’re making money, then you should be required to report that value to the irs. I don’t care which one you use (I mean I do, but in this case it’s not the specific point), what I’m saying is you don’t get to make money by having overvalued shares (by giving one profit number or the market), while not paying tax (by reporting a different number to irs)
- rb808 8y agoChoose the tax number. "Accounting for Growth" was a classic book written after the late 80's stock market bubble in the UK about how people were fooled by bad accounting and how to spot fraud. One of the main pieces of advice is that the tax number is usually more correct. If a company says it makes huge profit while paying little tax its likely not real profit.
- andrewstuart 8y agoSeems logical, but in the USA there always seem to be convoluted reasons why seemingly simple things can't happen, usually the result of vested interests pushing their agenda and getting their way for a very long time.
- skybrian 8y agoCompanies already sometimes report two numbers, based on GAAP and some other number that's supposedly more informative. I guess they'd do that even more, and stockholders would understand GAAP as the profits for tax purposes (so, lower) and do their own estimates of the "real" profits. Andrew Yang's proposal of doing a VAT might be another way around it, though I'd guess that probably has other problems.
- jopsen 8y agoThe thing is you're not required to pay tax on money that you reinvest in the business.. you would do away with that? It has upsides and downsides.. it certainly encourages reinvestment, rather than pulling the money out.