3 ms·
OTOH this is great that a private citizen can see an opportunity to give kids better education, and actually follow through that plan, making an example to repl
by nine_k 8y ago
OTOH this is great that a private citizen can see an opportunity to give kids better education, and actually follow through that plan, making an example to replicate and build upon.
In many countries, this is not a given: either directly forbidden or infeasible due to red tape.
- TaylorAlexander 8y agoIf the choice is a private citizen does or does not do this, then them doing it is better. But there is another possibility demonstrated in other countries: quality schools run by the government. In light of that possibility, I agree with the OP that it’s a shame this kind of thing is necessary. The US does pretty poorly on schooling compared to other countries AFAIK.
- dannypgh 8y ago+1 exactly this. LeBron did something wonderful, in one district. Government has far more means than an individual to scale that up to the whole country.
- nine_k 8y agoIf one school runs an experiment and it's a success, more schools (most of them state-run) can follow. If one school runs an experiment and it's a flop, it's a sad but it's limited to one school. If a government mandates a particular way of schooling, the initial good effect is multiplied faster. But the initial bad effect is multiplied, too. The fact that the US have a variety of school programs is a boon for the nation at large. They are mostly not great, but that's another problem. (See also e.g. http://www.paulgraham.com/nerds.html http://www.paulgraham.com/nerds.html for some good pointers at problems.)