7 ms·
Katie Bouman Accidentally Became the Face of the Black Hole Project
- SiempreViernes 8y agoNice little text, but doesn't live up to the clickbait title sadly. Would have been more interesting if the author had tried to follow the spread of the meme across some selected media, personally I first saw the claim made by CNN, but I don't know if they were the first. Still, there is some value in the article if it manage to calm down the hype without giving the incels a win. Lets hope the work Mervosh put in accomplish just that pays off!
- RandomInteger4 8y agoIncels? How is that relevant?
- reversecs 8y agoIncels had basically become an alias for scum. It's simply an insult. Now it reveals more about the person using it than the person being accused of it.
- laHiesh1 8y agoI've never understood the term incel (involuntarily celibate) as an insult, incels are just people who cannot get female/male attention for various reasons and some make up crazy conspiracy theories to explain it. Many of the people who do fit into this category are sad cases and deserve our sympathy rather than to be insulted and made fun of. The way I see it, it's no different than making fun of a person for having autism. Rather than making fun of these people, how about we help them overcome their issues?
- throw_away 8y agoIs it making fun, or is it fear? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2014_Isla_Vista_killings https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2014_Isla_Vista_killings https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toronto_van_attack https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toronto_van_attack
- RandomInteger4 8y agoYes, because it makes so much sense to generalize the actions of individuals to a wider group. Totally not a logical fallacy at all.
- laHiesh1 8y agoYou could say the same thing about Muslims and terror attacks. Using your logic, I could point to them and terrorist actions committed by those who identify as Islamist and use it to justify acts against innocent Muslims pushing those innocents to extremist factions within Islam. You don't help the issue by justifying ostracisation and bullying of those who are unable to seek female/male attention, it only pushes them to the extremes and extreme acts are what they commit in response.
- throw_away 8y agoI'm not justifying it in the slightest. Continuing your analogy, it would be like saying "I don't know why all these people have a problem with Islam, a religion of peace." without recognizing that some people did some things and here we are. I'm not saying that these peoples' reactions are the correct ones, but it's not like they all just spontaneously decided to hate on Muslims one day, randomly. It was almost certainly the wrong reaction, but there was a trigger. Your statement: > I've never understood the term incel (involuntarily celibate) as an insult, incels are just people who cannot get female/male attention for various reasons and some make up crazy conspiracy theories to explain it. makes it seem that you are unaware of this and think that the public's view of incels is just because it thinks they are losers or something. Incels were not even in the public's general awareness until these incidents.
- basetop 8y agoWhat does the article have to do with incels. People who blame everything on incels aren't any better than people who blame everything on feminists. It's just toxicity and no substance. Why reach for the lowest common denominator?
- SiempreViernes 8y agoUh, you don’t think the people sending death threats whenever a woman is lauded for a technical accomplishment is relevant for how this story developed? I guess I could have called them ”hateful men” insted, but I doubth people would have been less offended by that term.
- azeotropic 8y agoThis article reminds me of Dan Rather's "fake but accurate" posturing when he got caught. There was no accident here. The media had a story it believed desperately needed to be told, so they told it, facts be damned. This is who they are and what they do.
- cheez 8y agoI think it's unfortunate from two perspectives: 1. I have zero experience seeing women in STEM treated badly. I'm sure it exists, but I've never seen it. Exactly the contrary. So whenever I personally see these articles, I think it's a solution looking for a problem. For example, see this article: https://www.express.co.uk/news/world/1095957/Google-news-gender-pay-gap-workers-men-woman https://www.express.co.uk/news/world/1095957/Google-news-gen... 2. I'm not sure how much Katie likes to be reduced down to what is between her legs given the combined years of dedication it took to be able to achieve the results that the team achieved. In general, can we please applaud the people and not the identities? It's so sad to see this approach to celebrating achievements. I don't want my children to be labelled based on something they have no control over. A silver lining in this cloud is that "normies" don't really think this way, it's just the media.
- arcticfox 8y agoI loved the image of her, it's such an all-time classic, but I agree that her treatment was unfortunate. It seemed like a rush to narrative to me, which was totally unnecessary given how special the moment clearly was. To me, it kind of casts a pall over both such an amazing discovery and amazing moment of humanity. Remarkably I think today was the first time I recall seeing the name of even the director of the project (much less other teammates who may have had major roles) after having seen various posts about this over the past week.
- whatshisface 8y agoThe Twitter/news world (it's amazing how closely they track each other) casts a pall over great achievements regularly. Remember the Hawaiian shirt guy? It's time to transced the reality TV stuff, amazing thing are happening.
- SiempreViernes 8y agoThey did put in a lot of effort to prevent there being any ”the one person behind the picture” talk, from the grand gesture of having 4 simultaneous press conferences around the world, to small details like everyone starting the image reconstruction code at the same time on their laptops. If you go back I bet you will see other names in the texts you’ve read, but the collaboration itself didn’t try to sell anyone like the brains behind the picture, so there is not much to naturally focus on.
- aaron695 8y agoFlag the story and move on.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- diydsp 8y agoin my feeds numerous in-place edits of an initial graphic with text competed with varying narratives and cross-outs. people used them to project their personal beliefs. hard to get any real information.
- prawn 8y agoI found it really interesting to read the comments on the post about "LeBron James' school"^ and the first major post about the black hole image. The recent LBJ story was a decent and constructive discussion, though I do remember when it was first announced here (or r/NBA) that a few people thought his role was overplayed. There are some parallels between both stories with what gets media attention (a name and face) and what can serve to inspire (athlete with undereducated kids, woman in STEM, etc). ^ https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19668821 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19668821
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- nitwit005 8y agoI'm sure part of that was people wanting to promote women in STEM, but there also seems to be a lot of people tweaking headlines to find what gets the most attention. People love reddit karma, and news sites want to bring in the visitors.
- anjc 8y agoI'm confused about this. People said her code contribution on the repo was minimal. Others in the field came out and said "yes but her algorithm was key here, not lines of code". Fine. Her own statement then says that "no one algorithm was key, it was a group effort", but her colleagues say her algorithm wasn't used at all. The obfuscation doesn't seem accidental at all. Why is a person sexist and homophobic [1] for wondering why two major news articles say the opposite thing [1,2]: [1]: "Katherine Bouman, a 29-year-old postdoctoral researcher who developed an algorithm that was key to capturing the stunning visual." https://www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2019/04/12/trolls-hijacked-scientists-image-attack-katie-bouman-they-picked-wrong-astrophysicist/?utm_term=.3938e4714e12 https://www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2019/04/12/trolls-hija... [2]: "While she led the development of an algorithm to take a picture of a black hole, an effort that was the subject of a TED Talk she gave in 2016, her colleagues said that technique was not ultimately used to create this particular image." https://www.nytimes.com/2019/04/11/science/katie-bouman-black-hole.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/04/11/science/katie-bouman-blac...
- Canadauni 8y agoThe quote that you included as part of [1] doesn't seem to be present in the article you linked. Getting down to your question I am not sure the fault lies with those who are wondering about the difference between two opposing statements in the media. The piece I take issue is that as soon as the picture of her with the image of the black hole started to go viral the first thing many people did was check her contributions to a repo on github to quantify the code that she wrote for the project as a way to measure her which ultimately seems like something someone would do out of feelings of inadequacy.
- anjc 8y agoMy mistake, it was in the other article I linked to. Her current/future employers, her colleagues, and every academic's employers and colleagues, want to know contributions. Some fields make you explicitly list them for each paper. No doubt feelings of inadequacy feed into this at some point, but it's part of the job and isn't saved for just measuring women.