4 ms·
> Your statement of averages doesn't seem related to parents point, and does not contradict my point. FWIW, I'm not trying to contradict you, I'm trying to und
by dahart 8y ago
> Your statement of averages doesn't seem related to parents point, and does not contradict my point.
FWIW, I'm not trying to contradict you, I'm trying to understand you. But, above you said "Here you imply that renters are people who cannot afford to buy a house." I was responding directly to that. Isn't is actually true that the majority of renters are not smart stock/bond market investors, and that the majority of renters cannot afford a down payment on a house, even if they want to, and that's why they're renting?
> I would like to see numbers to back it up. It's very easy to lose track of how much money you spent on your house that you wouldn't have spent if you were renting...
I was talking about the sale price of a house (getting your money back) compared to paying rent (not getting your money back). You want evidence that most housing sales aren't normally 0 and a total loss for the owner, is that what you mean?
It's fairly easy to Google average house return rates, I guess, but I honestly don't think my statement that housing returns aren't normally 0 needs any numbers to back it up. Here's the first hit I see: "Average annual returns in long-term real estate investing vary by the area of concentration in the sector. Average 20-year returns in the commercial real estate slightly outperform the S&P 500 Index, running at around 9.5%. Residential and diversified real estate investments do a bit better, averaging 10.6%. Real estate investment trusts (REITS) perform best, with an average annual return of 11.8%."
https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/060415/what-average-annual-return-typical-long-term-investment-real-estate-sector.asp https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/060415/what-average...
> check out this calculator
Thank you, this calculator does what I was asking for -- it compares buying and later selling a house to renting for that same duration.
To be honest, and just for the sake of discussion, my reaction is that I'm somewhat skeptical about it, and here's specifically why:
- It ends up calculating twice the recurring costs of buying vs renting. It's not immediately obvious that any of the variables are wrong, but the sum total doesn't seem very plausible, it doesn't really pass the smell test. A landlord is simply not going to rent for less than maintenance costs. Renting should be assumed by default to cost more than buying in the long term. All things being equal, the maintenance costs are the same, the difference is the landlord's markup.
- For everywhere I've ever lived (CA, NY & UT), the price that it calculates for rent as "equivalent" would not be able to get you an equivalent house, not even close. It's one thing to say an equivalent dollar amount exists, but it's another thing entirely to have such options. Generally speaking, the same monthly dollar amount spent on rent vs buy is going to net you a bigger space if you buy than if you rent.
- It assumes renters don't pay utilities, which is often not the case. But, again, it needs to be assumed that renters and buyers both pay the same utilities somehow, regardless of whether they're paying the landlord or the utility companies. It almost doesn't make sense to factor utilities into the comparison, especially only on one side of it.
Anyway, I totally buy that there's opportunity cost in a down payment, and that someone could use that money to invest in other ways that might outperform rent. I do not buy that there's any other savings possible when renting in a free market, generally speaking. (I'm specifically excluding rent control in my thinking here.)
Personally, I can easily say after having rented for a decade and owned two houses for a decade, that the houses were a far and away better deal financially than renting, like not even close. So much so that I very much regret not buying earlier. All in all, including maintenance and remodels on both houses, buying houses has increased my savings considerably, where renting decreased it.
My experience makes me wonder whether arguments in favor of renting aren't somewhat designed to make people who don't have a choice about renting feel okay about their situation. That's not necessarily a bad thing in my mind, even if the argument doesn't line up with reality.
- twiceaday 8y agoTo simplify the grand-parent said "all flowers are white", I said "no, some are yellow" and you said "isn't it true that most of them are white?" Your statement is probably true but is not related to my point that the grand-parent comment is overly simplistic and needs to be qualified. > I was talking about the sale price of a house (getting your money back) compared to paying rent (not getting your money back). This is biased framing that favors owning. In both cases you sign up for ongoing sunk costs and for an investment. You sell your investment then subtract the sunk costs, that is what we are comparing. > You want evidence that most housing sales aren't normally 0 and a total loss for the owner, is that what you mean? Even this is a bit biased. If you simply look at home sales you will miss all of the people who are not selling because their house value is too low for them. So they sit there making all kinds of sacrifices to avoid selling. > It's fairly easy to Google average house return rates, I guess, but I honestly don't think my statement that housing returns aren't normally 0 needs any numbers to back it up. It doesn't seem that easy and I think the fact that you don't think they need backing up tips your hand. > "Average annual returns in long-term real estate investing vary by the area of concentration in the sector. Average 20-year returns in the commercial real estate slightly outperform the S&P 500 Index, running at around 9.5%. Residential and diversified real estate investments do a bit better, averaging 10.6%. Real estate investment trusts (REITS) perform best, with an average annual return of 11.8%." I don't buy these un-sourced numbers for a second. For starters, averages are completely useless here. A few booming places can hide thousands of cities that are underwater. Zillow [1] has median data for the entire country for the last 10 years and it shows prices went from 170k to 230k. That is 3% yoy. And you can even lie with this number because it doesn't capture variance. 3% could be 6% in half the country and 0% in the other half. Unlike with the stock market you cannot fractionally diversify unless you are mega rich. This 3% is also not purely profit as it is missing local property taxes and other sunk costs. Also let's not forget inflation is 2-3% yoy... In terms of renters taking on the owners costs, sure renting is more freeing so the renters pay a premium for a short contract and no down-payment and such. Sometimes that is done as a choice and not because its the only option. And some fees like repairs are amortized by landlords as they own many units. It's not the same as you hiring a third party to fix something in your house, it will cost more for you. And, again, to my point, this varies by locality and living situation. That calculator is a great starting point to get you to realize all of the factors that go into making the decision. It's actually still missing a lot of them. Any diligent investor should make their own in spreadsheets before making that big decision. [1] https://www.zillow.com/home-values/ https://www.zillow.com/home-values/