5 ms·
I wonder if the Mastodon community will pick up Keybase chat as the de facto chat option with this integration in place. Chat or private messaging has always be
by ocdtrekkie 8y ago
I wonder if the Mastodon community will pick up Keybase chat as the de facto chat option with this integration in place. Chat or private messaging has always been considered the weak link of the fediverse since it's easy for bad servers to mishandle "private" toots.
- codetrotter 8y agoDo you mean for encryption or do you mean using their servers also?
- coldacid 8y agoMy bet would be both. After all, why handle all the dirty work of implementing real-time chat that works across multiple different sites when you can just plug in Keybase instead? After all, if you're using it for encryption you already require people to have a Keybase account to have their chats encrypted.
- insomniacity 8y agoYeah, interesting point - this could actually pick up chat functionality for a whole heap of sites that don't have it, but are prepared to do the Keybase integration work.
- 0xb100db1ade 8y agoI wish that Keybase could work with the Signal team on something. Signal has a lot of experience in UI [1] and security, and Keybase had the identity proofs. I'd love to see them work together rather than compete. [1] Signal UI used to be horrible but as of the past few months it's improved a ton! It's now my preferred SMS client.
- giggles_giggles 8y ago>Signal UI used to be horrible but as of the past few months it's improved a ton! That's funny, I've had the opposite experience. Once I got everyone I know to start using it and was completely locked-in, I started having all kinds of weird issues. My favorite is when my phone has been off awhile. After I turn it back on, I get a notification for every message I sent/received on another device while it was off. Usually takes about 30 minutes for it to fully sync, buzzing and/or producing popups for every message along the way. I have about a dozen equally frustrating issues I could, if I had the time, enumerate. And of course because it's free, there's no real support. Signal has been a huge disappointment for me. I'm preparing to move back to regular SMS, but now I have to untangle all of the users like my mother that I convinced to use Signal. Caveat emptor!
- pault 8y agoYou'd rather opt in to global passive surveillance than deal with an inconvenient UX?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- giggles_giggles 8y agoIt's not inconvenient, it's broken. The issue I described above is not the only misbehavior to which I'm frequently subjected. Another example: messages are delayed, often. Recently I failed to reply to an urgent text about a medical diagnosis from my fiance due to Signal failing to push the message to my phone. This is unacceptable behavior from a critical application. Do I get on a soapbox about how surveillance is terrible and miss being there for her by insisting on using Signal? No! I want her to be able to get in contact with me if there's an emergency, and that's the #1 priority.
- coldacid 8y agoIf you include in "bad servers" ones that censor and ostracise instances that offer more freedom to their users, yes.
- kstrauser 8y agoYou mean, ones that block spam farms and troll infestations? If so, that would leave a tiny little awful network. There's a reason that Mastodon is more pleasant than Twitter, and it's largely because its federation model penalizes both ban-happy and completely unmoderated peers.
- phoe-krk 8y agoHow is Keybase chat federated? Using a centralized service defeats the purpose of a decentralized Fediverse.
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoIt's not, but decentralization isn't super effective for private channels of communication, particularly where neither end is running the software in question. (Most Mastodon users aren't site admins.) But presumably if proving a Keybase user and a Mastodon user are the same is given, when a Mastodon user wants to contact another outside of Mastodon, Keybase Chat may be the new default choice.
- rickycook 8y agoi think that’s pretty incorrect tbh; xmpp/otr, and matrix handle federation and private chat/encryption just fine id much prefer to see chat that’s just thinly wrapped in a pgp implementation that gets its keys from keybase (maybe just initial secrets transferred with pgp for handshake or something)
- phoe-krk 8y ago> but decentralization isn't super effective for private channels of communication The two examples of that not being the case are OTR XMPP and PGP e-mail. > particularly where neither end is running the software in question You cannot have useful encrypted communication if your software does not support it.
- silvermast 8y agoPlease no. Centralization is always abused (eventually). Email + mastodon + IRC = happy little hackers.
- eridius 8y agoEmail is de-facto centralized at this point, with the overwhelming majority of email going through a small handful of giant providers. I don't remember the number anymore but some scary-high percentage of all email volume goes through Google servers.
- eitland 8y ago1. There are still multiple options working options within the same ecosystem. And yes you can still self-host or pay to host[0]. Unlike on WhatsApp, Telegram or Signal where you have to choose one (or more) providers. 2. I find it weird how busy we are as a community are: scaring each other away from the solutions we should use by pushing Joe Average in front of us (like the post in this thread about mastodon.com being up for sale). [0]: yes, there are problems. But FWIW mail disappeared before Gmail as well: I have memories of customers complaining about mail from "central USA" (or something) not arriving and after hassling our email provider and having them hassling their connections mail suddenly started to arrive. (And no I don't think it was acceptable then and I don't think it is acceptable now.)
- jdormit 8y agoWhy not Matrix? A federated chat protocol to go with a federated social media protocol.