5 ms·
Yeah, but not just unmeasurable by like a guy with a measuring device, unmeasurable in the sense that it _can't effect anything at all_, right? (if it caused an
by jrochkind1 8y ago
Yeah, but not just unmeasurable by like a guy with a measuring device, unmeasurable in the sense that it _can't effect anything at all_, right? (if it caused an effect of any sort you could eventually measure or observe in any way... nope).
To say that time is "really" continuous under such circumstances seems like a weird philosophical claim.
- whatshisface 8y agoFortunately it's not a philosophical claim - after all even if it was demonstrated experimentally that time moved in frames like a movie, it could still be a movie played on a projector whose reels spun in continuous time. There's no way to know "what it ultimately is," only the most ultimate thing seen so far.
- jrochkind1 8y agoTalking about what might exist that the laws of nature as we currently understand them would prevent us from ever having any evidence whatsoever of... it's def not a scientific claim or inquiry, sounds philosophical to me. If it can't be observed, like it's even theoretically impossible to observe it or have evidence of it, ever... it's not science.
- TeMPOraL 8y ago> If it can't be observed, like it's even theoretically impossible to observe it or have evidence of it, ever... it's not science. More than that. It simply doesn't exist in any meaningful sense and it's a waste of time to even think about it. What cannot be observed in principle has exactly zero impact on the universe. That's pretty much a definiton of "not existing".
- coldtea 8y ago>More than that. It simply doesn't exist in any meaningful sense and it's a waste of time to even think about it. The irony is it's actually a philosophy (a philosophy of science among several in particular) saying the above. It's not anything scientifically observed itself that says that when something can't be measured "it simply doesn't exist in any meaningful sense and it's a waste of time to even think about it".
- 8bitsrule 8y agoScience is not always aware that it has axioms. Historically, absolute time, absolute space, Euclidean geometry, stuff like that. No place for, say, the qualia which motivate it ... beauty, elegance, the like.
- whatshisface 8y agoEuclidian geometry was literally based on axioms from day one.
- coldtea 8y agoWhat the parent means is science doesn't always know it has implicit axioms. And that Euclidean geometry itself is only one possible geometry, but took us several millennia (until e.g. Lobachevsky) to find out -- it was taken as a kind of axiom itself, like absolute time etc.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoYes, this is philosophy of science and technically an axiom. But it's not an arbitrary one. It's saying that "it exists <=> something would be different about the world if it didn't exist <=> it's in principle observable (though its impact) <=> can be studied by science". Call it my lack of imagination, but I don't believe it's even possible to disagree with this axiom; alternatives don't make any kind of sense. EDIT: looking at this "axiom" from another angle. Imagine that I claim that atoms are really built out of Zeta faces, that are exactly like quarks, but have smily faces etched on them. I also claim that it's in principle impossible to tell a difference between a Zeta face and a quark (hypothetical quark, after all it's all Zeta faces). They just are there. At this point you could correctly observe that since the universe would look precisely no different whether or not there are smiley faces on quarks - there's not a bit of information distinguishing these two hypotheses - my claim is absolutely meaningless and a waste of time. This generalizes to all kinds of invisible, unmeasurable magic faries under the bed, etc. (It's probably a well-trodden philosophical ground, but I don't know who to read to find a decent discussion of it.)
- ngcc_hk 8y agoWhat cannot be observed even indirectly is a better phase. But even that may not be ok. Qm cannot be observed by itself and it collapses once observed. What before collapse cannot be observed. It is not even indirectly observed. Not Like quake which may break in high enough energy. Qm is based on unobserable. The cat before you observe is ... you never know. Observe change it.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoI think "in principle" is still better - what it means that you can't observe it directly, indirectly, infer its existence, etc. There's not a single bit of universe state that would be different depending on existence of phenomenon under question (if even a single bit of state flipped, you could in principle observe it). Qm - I assume you mean wave functions and their collapse - are an explanatory mathematical abstraction, but they follow rules grounded in observational data. You don't say "wave function collapsed there, only it's impossible to measure it"; that's meaningless. We say that the wave function collapses when we find some observation changing from one state to another in a way that implies there were superpositions of state involved in the middle.
- oarabbus_ 8y agoThank you, you eloquently expressed the point I was trying to make. To say "we know that quantity Y can never be measurable or observable below discrete length X... but also, Y is continuous and can be subdivided below X, just trust us on this one" doesn't sound like science. Philosophical at best.
- coldtea 8y agoPhilosophy is not just saying random stuff and "trust us". And inversely, science is not just measuring -- that's the naive positivist (and later Popperian) view of what scientists do. For example: As Thomas Kuhn (1961) argues, scientific theories are usually accepted long before quantitative methods for testing them become available. The reliability of newly introduced measurement methods is typically tested against the predictions of the theory rather than the other way around. In Kuhn’s words, “The road from scientific law to scientific measurement can rarely be traveled in the reverse direction” (1961: 189). For example, Dalton’s Law, which states that the weights of elements in a chemical compound are related to each other in whole-number proportions, initially conflicted with some of the best known measurements of such proportions. It is only by assuming Dalton’s Law that subsequent experimental chemists were able to correct and improve their measurement techniques (1961: 173). https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/measurement-science/#EpiMea https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/measurement-science/#EpiM...
- jrochkind1 8y agoAll good points. It's not simple or mechanical, and it's often erroneous, but the realm of science is still the realm of that which can be observed and measured, and refuted or confirmed by observation and measurement. Trying to figure out how to do that is what makes it science. It's possible the Uncertainty Principle is wrong. One can come up with theories that it is wrong. And what sorts of observations might hypothetically observe or refute them. As far as I know, there is no serious science doubting HUP at present. (Which doesn't prove it's right, it's just the current state of things). But simply speculating about what things might exist that current scientific understanding says scientific laws would prevent us from observing or measuring or seeing any effects of whatsoever -- is still not science. It's not that you can't have a scientific theory which current measurements seem to refute and still press for it (your Dalton's law example). It's that you can't have a scientific theory with no even theoretical way to refute or confirm it by observation. That's not a scientific theory.
- coldtea 8y ago>To say that time is "really" continuous under such circumstances seems like a weird philosophical claim. Actually what you say is the weird philosophical claim. It's like saying Australia didn't really exist when we couldn't observe it (or see any effects from it reach us). The thing is, to say it could be continuous even if that's not observable might be wrong. But not because it can't be both continuous and not observable: just because it can also be discreet and not observable, and we can't tell which of two it is for sure. Whether we (or any observer imaginable) can observe effects or not, doesn't mean it's not one or the other.
- oarabbus_ 8y ago>It's like saying Australia didn't really exist when we couldn't observe it (or see any effects from it reach us). This is a straw man, and I think you know that. It's more like saying Atlantis doesn't exist, and, well, to the best of our knowledge - it doesn't. I'd be happy to re-evaluate upon receiving evidence that Atlantis may have existed, just as QM physicists should be happy to re-evaluate when sub-Planck-scale phenomena can possibly be observed using a theory which is also consistent with the rest of our observations of the world. Oh and an even better analogy than Atlantis - it's like someone saying Australia didn't really exist when we couldn't observe it, and claiming they would prove it by sailing from Chile to Africa without encountering any large land masses. So no, he's not making any weird philosophical claim at all.
- coldtea 8y ago>This is a straw man, and I think you know that. It's more like saying Atlantis doesn't exist, and, well, to the best of our knowledge - it doesn't. I'd be happy to re-evaluate upon receiving evidence that Atlantis may have existed I don't see much difference. If you're "happy to re-evaluate" (e.g. open to the possibility) then the answer (even re: Atlantis") is "I don't know if it exists", not "doesn't exist".