3 ms·
Uncertainty principle says...probably not. It's impossible to make a complete copy of the pattern. Even aside from that -- it's unlikely to be practical to sca
by lupire 8y ago
Uncertainty principle says...probably not. It's impossible to make a complete copy of the pattern.
Even aside from that -- it's unlikely to be practical to scan something down to the smallest level level of matter, because the tools we use to manipulate things can't manipulate things smaller than their own finest details.
So there's a "glass wall" in that you can only replicate things less finely detailed than the replicator. That works fine for macroscopic things (that's why you can buy a 3D printer today), but is implausible for things that we believe to be as finely detailed as our machines.
- lisper 8y ago> Uncertainty principle says...probably not. It's impossible to make a complete copy of the pattern. That depends on what "the pattern" is. You can make an "exact" copy of a digital file, but that's because the semantics of digital data don't depend on the fine details of the physical representation (that's the whole point of going digital). We don't yet know what level of detail of our physical state actually matters. If you take a single atom in your brain and move it somewhere else, does that matter? Probably not. What about ten atoms? Again, probably not. But at some point as the number goes up the answer must change. We don't know where the boundary is, and we don't know how close it is to the theoretical and technological limits of copying. But I don't think we can rule out the possibility of cloning a human brain in principle based on current knowledge.
- pontifier 8y agoThat's what the "Heisinberg compensators" in star trek fix. I heard this phrase in an episode once, and decided to figure out how that could even work... What I came up with was the idea that the scanning stage doesn't need to gather exact data because it really doesn't matter. You just need to get averages, and then build up a model that matches the statistics... (you don't need to discover the exact energy and momentum of every particle, just measure the temperature) Basically you get teleporter jpeg compression... good enough to fool you, just don't use it too many times without keeping the raw data:)
- Zardoz84 8y ago"Heisinberg compensators" it's a clever lie that La Forge uses to fool Moriarty on a chapter.
- pontifier 8y agoThey are mentioned several times, but no description is given for how they might work. https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/Heisenberg_compensator https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/Heisenberg_compensator