7 ms·
Cursive Seemed to Go the Way of Quills and Parchment. Now It’s Coming Back
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoI remember in high school I tried to write a letter to my older brother in California. I had forgotten how to write in cursive - too much hand-lettering on my computer printouts etc. So I just hand-lettered the letter. Today (decades later) I use cursive exclusively for signing things. And that's a mess.
- lainga 8y agoHow often do you handwrite?
- JoeAltmaier 8y agoAlmost never. Maybe a note in a notebook, and I hand-letter.
- ovi256 8y agoSame here. My wrist hurt when initialing and signing a long contract recently, and the notary said it's a common experience.
- tdeck 8y agoI was born in 1991. I learned to write cursive in school, but I can't comfortably read it. Whenever I get a card from an older relative I've got to slowly puzzle over some of the words. Apart from the odd instructor who wrote on the board in cursive, these occasional personal notes are my only practice. These days most people default to what used to be called "printing" so it's rarely a big deal. If we want to bring back cursive, there needs to be more of an acknowledgement that reading and writing are different things, and need to be practiced differently. When I was learning Morse code, it was understood that sending and receiving are different skills (e.g. I can send at 25 WPM but can only copy at about 12 WPM). The same doesn't seem to be true about cursive education.
- anon491throw 8y agoWhat's interesting is that difficult to read / "ugly" font text is more memorable than easier-to-read text. Therefore, memory-item checklists, insightful quotes and other bits of important text should use Comic Sans, cursive, etc. to achieve memorability, whereas most ubiquitous affordance labels and signage shouldn't.
- gruez 8y agoSource on this? You'd think that if it worked, all the ads you see would be in ugly fonts, seeing how well adtech optimizes.
- jsty 8y agohttps://qz.com/1417818/hard-to-read-fonts-can-help-boost-your-memory/ https://qz.com/1417818/hard-to-read-fonts-can-help-boost-you... Here's a font designed to leverage the effect for improving recall
- tdeck 8y agoVery interesting! Though it seems like you'd grow accustomed to this font and lessen it's effect if used regularly as part of a study process.
- cjslep 8y agoI lasted one semester in Russian class thanks in part to the cursive writing full of what looks like to English speakers as cursive u and w mixed with half-height dotless cursive i's. It was really hard to read and write Cyrillic like that.
- paleotrope 8y agoI lost the ability to easily write English cursive when I learned to write Russian cursive. слышу is my go to word when I want to show people how crazy Russian cursive can be.
- musicale 8y agoI recommend cursive italic, a form of writing that is beautiful and fast to write, but much easier to learn than looped cursive, since it reuses the printed letter forms and avoids complicated joins. As a bonus, your handwriting resembles Shakespeare's.
- burfog 8y agoThat is a fine recommendation for people in the UK. It will be readable there. Americans aren't usually used to it. Americans normally use D'Nealian. It is similar to the older Palmer Method, which in turn is similar to the older Spencerian script.
- geomark 8y agoDo you have any examples? I might have adopted one of those methods but don't remember where my style came from. Edit: Found examples on Wikipedia. That's not how I write. I guess mine is less cursive-y and more print-y.
- jvagner 8y agoDo you have recommendations for exposing/introducing/teaching some kind of cursive to an American home-schooled 15 year old? On the one hand, he's in college chemistry & physics on the side... on the other hand, we have funny gaps like this that we know we should do something about. [Or maybe not...]
- burfog 8y agoI did exactly that. I had kids studying for AP Chemistry ages 10 to 16, and I think that is when I sat them all down to learn handwriting. I hadn't planned to teach it, because I thought I never used it, but then one day I wrote a non-technical essay (something I hadn't done in many years) and felt a strangely strong urge to use cursive. I sat everybody down at a table and had them copy my text from a whiteboard. I wrote sentences about random crazy stuff. I would then go over their text, making them fix each spot that could create ambiguity. Explain the ambiguity so that they understand why it is a problem. (if your 'f' has a lower loop that is wide or doesn't descend much, it could be confused with a 'b', etc.) Most days we'd do a few dozen sentences. It wasn't long before they started to be decent at it. I sure know what you mean about the funny gaps. It is easy to forget something while focusing on other stuff. At one point I had a 14-year-old who couldn't really read. I threw him into AP Chemistry, making him read the book out loud so I could correct him. That worked! It was miserable at first, because he needed correction every few words, but now he reads well.
- Arbalest 8y agoIt frustrates me that older generations lament the loss of cursive in the curriculum, but refuse to acknowledge that it overall reduces the readability. Not everyone is a born artist, and the evidence is quite clear that it isn't a magic bullet (or else everyone would have readable cursive). I know I don't write that well, but because the letters aren't linked up there's less ability to scrawl, so they tend to be reasonably interpretable.
- burfog 8y agoAn artist would make less-readable cursive. To make readable cursive, you need to practice following rules precisely. You need to develop hand coordination, which is probably of general use for things like sewing and surgery and removing slivers. I think a big trouble is bad instruction. Somebody with a clue needs to carefully study your writing, find the flaws, and insist that you get things correct. Some things about letter forms don't matter much, while other things matter a great deal. For example, the distinction between a rounded curve and a point is usually important. Many teachers won't know this. Also, individualized attention isn't easy to get in a large classroom.
- cgriswald 8y agoI am left-handed and although my cursive was perfectly fine otherwise (properly sized loops, etc.), I was removed from class and given special instruction (by someone... I think she was not a teacher, but a volunteer aide or something) in order to correct my left-leaning slant. It 'worked', but the cost was my cursive was significantly worse. She frequently was out of the room, so I just went very slowly to get enough 'good' cursive to satisfy them. To this day, unless I am really thinking about it, my right-leaning cursive is much uglier than my left-leaning cursive.
- burfog 8y agoYou are at a disadvantage, and so you'll need more practice. Perhaps it would help to get a writing tool that doesn't need much force. Funny story: I'm right handed. In high school, I badly injured my right hand. When I first tried to write with my left hand, I found that it seemed easy. My handwriting was perfect except for one thing: it was a mirror image! Switching to the proper direction didn't degrade the quality, but it really really slowed me down.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoConsidering the limited time available to schools for teaching and available to kids for homework I find it very hard to justify teaching cursive in 2019. It is no longer a required skill for being a functional member of society, it's not even in the top half of the "nice to have" list.
- ajmarsh 8y agoHow is there time for this, and not a financial literacy class? Kids are graduating HS with no real life skills to speak of yet we have time for this?
- Technetium_Hat 8y agoThere is a financial literacy class.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoIt is not in the government's interest to strongly support the teaching of financial literacy because a population that is financially literate is going to demand more financial responsibility from government. While there's no conspiracy to prevent teaching financial literacy, there's just little incentive to actually do it because the status quo thrives on its absence.
- barry-cotter 8y agoThey teach cursive in elementary school, whose primary function is socialisation and childcare, not education. I taught kindergarten (in English) to children who were native speakers of Chinese for four years. I know you can take a six year old with minimal exposure to English to grade level reading fluency in 50 weeks of 30 minute lessons 5 days a week because I’ve done it. I’m reliably informed by Chinese teachers that you can take a child who speaks Chinese (Mandarin), from illiterate to within the normal range of writing skill within three years, at more or less any age from elementary school to the end of high school. I regret I lost the citation but John Taylor Gatto writes in one of his books that you can teach a nine year old to read English in 40 hours of instruction. I believe it, and the experience of teachers in Sudbury schools is that you can teach the entire elementary school math curriculum to a 12 year old in under 40 hours. The lowest figure I’ve heard for that feat is 20 hours. Homework in elementary school is just a waste of time, theft from children and their families. The research is clear that it’s ineffective in aiding learning prior to middle school at the earliest. An institution dedicated to teaching children would look very different to elementary, middle or high schools in any country’s public education system. They’d use mastery based learning rather than age based progression and spaced repetition at the most basic. Those particular educational techniques are more than a century old and used more or less nowhere. On a less iconoclastic note German elementary schools are mostly half day and French ones full day. There is no real difference in their graduates readiness for middle and high school. And kindergarten as mostly play systems have no worse and often better results than kindergarten as school lite systems. In Finland they don’t even teach kindergarteners to read. They do fine in the end. Elementary school is not primarily about education. Homework is not about education at all at that level.
- ChrisRR 8y agoIs it an american thing not to learn cursive? I'm from the UK, 30 years old and everyone was taught "joined-up writing" as it was called. Nowadays I write about half and half. Joining up letters where it's natural to, and leaving some unjoined.
- zdragnar 8y ago32, American, was forced to use cursive almost exclusively through I think the 8th grade. After that, everyone stopped caring what we did. Most students switched away from cursive almost immediately, though a few adopted a mix of print and cursive letters.
- wmil 8y agoUS and Canada use the "Palmer Method", which is much more stylized than "joined up". There are a lot of loops and odd shapes to keep then quill nib straight. Most people realize that it's a complete waste of time when using a ball point pen.
- scatters 8y agoAmerican cursive is an archaic, artificial form of writing, essentially a calligraphic hand minimally adapted for everyday use. Unfortunately, its existence and the attachment of older generations to it prevent the US from adopting a more practical style along the lines of UK cursive.
- eli_gottlieb 8y agoI was required to learn cursive as a child in school, since at the time, you couldn't expect everyone to have a computer available. They even enforced the use of cursive for writing assignments all the way up through middle school. To be honest, for just writing stuff down with a pen, I still use it. I just don't see any point in switching to block print, since anything that needs to be "properly" block-printed, I'll end up typing.
- azhenley 8y ago> Part of being an American is being able to read cursive writing. What?? This is asinine.
- jhbadger 8y agoThe argument, such as it is, is that many of the founding documents of the US were originally written in cursive. But they were eventually printed for distribution so the argument doesn't really make sense. It would be like saying Britons should not only learn medieval handwriting but medieval Latin as well given that their Magna Carta was written that way.
- ummwhat 8y agoCall me uncultured but I say it should damn well stay dead. Cursive is a waste of everyone's time. It adds nothing to the language. Remembering how to do it is about as skillful as remembering all the Minecraft crafting recipes, and it is merely a historical accident that one of these is seen as a mark of education and the other a mark of immaturity.
- DiffEq 8y agoSo it certainly is not a waste of everyone's time, and it does add to the language but only in the sense that it is, can be, and should be, considered a form of art. And last time I checked beauty is not a waste of time (well not always). I learned italics instead of cursive in the 1980s; I was in the first year they dropped cursive. I lamented not learning cursive when I saw my mom's handwriting...but I also lament not learning art when I was young when I see people effortlessly sketch out a dog or some thing like that. Yet my lament is not enough to invest the time to learn those skills; I would rather learn some other thing; but I am not everybody and I know some people that certainly love cursive and have learned different variations of cursive and some have gone into calligraphy. So I think it should be some form of an elective, just like art class. Perhaps that is the proper place.
- RandomInteger4 8y agoThen take a college elective and stop wasting everyone else's time because of your lament.
- DiffEq 8y agoUm...if you read what I wrote, this is essentially what I said.
- bfrydl 8y agoTypical cursive is a form of connected writing originally designed for pens and quills with flexible nibs. Letters like ℓ have loops because when writing with these tools the downstroke is thicker than the upstroke. The result is a recognizable lowercase L with a thin stroke on the side. It's easy to read even if you've never had to before. This form of writing was dated as soon as the ballpoint pen was invented, which was in the 19th century. Writing it with a pencil makes even less sense. By tradition we have clung to this terrible writing style instead of introducing something more sensible and modern like italic cursive, which is connected but without loops.
- reaperducer 8y agoCursive exists not because of quills and ink but because it’s easier on hand muscles when writing long form. People used to write hundreds of pages a week. The letters I sent to friends when I was in college were probably 20 or 30 pages each, and several went out each week. Writing that much in print hurts my hand, even today. Last year I switched back to cursive in my daily work notebook and it’s reduced hand pain greatly.
- bfrydl 8y agoCursive in general, meaning letters connected together to minimize pen lifts, still exists because it's easier and faster than block lettering. It's the particular kind of looped cursive taught in America that was designed for dip pens and other older instruments. Writing this script with a modern pen or pencil trades legibility for writing speed and comfort. My point is that if we want to keep teaching kids connected writing, there are cursive scripts that are easier to teach, easier to write, and easier to read than the one we've clung to for so long.
- talideon 8y ago> This form of writing was dated as soon as the ballpoint pen was invented, which was in the 19th century. While technically correct, that's all this is. Loud might've invented the ballpoint in the late 19th century, but they weren't of even remotely practical use until the late 1930s with Bíró's refinements, and even then they only took off after WW2. > By tradition we have clung to this terrible writing style instead of introducing something more sensible and modern like italic cursive, which is connected but without loops. That's wholly a matter of personal style. Plenty of people learn and use cursive styles that lack loops.
- booleandilemma 8y agoDo they not teach cursive anymore in schools? That’s a new one for me.
- ravenstine 8y agoThe common discussion around this topic reminds me of how people got upset about Pluto being demoted to a "dwarf planet", or how they value spending hours of one's life reading fiction novels while scoffing at shows and video games as lower forms of art. I know older folks who think it's a bad thing that their nieces and nephews aren't being taught cursive handwriting. People have a visceral reaction to change, especially when it comes to things that were romanticized, or at least emphasized in childhood. Knowing how to write in cursive is like knowing how to churn butter, how to tie a horse to a hitching post, or (more aptly) using a typewriter. Said skills might be selectively useful, but they are generally obsolete. It's great that people want to know that I have to do those things, but don't expect me to have to learn outdated things that have no use for me.
- linuxftw 8y agoLearning how to write fluently on paper and the ability to read older source documents is a skill. Learning that Columbus showed up in 1492 is trivia. Public school spends >50% of time on trivia, and skills are being removed. I consider written language a part of a language culture. Getting rid of cursive writing is like telling people they can't speak Spanish because it's an outdated language and everyone should just use English because it's more modern, and all the computer stuff is in English anyway.
- PhasmaFelis 8y agoLatin would be a better comparison than Spanish here. It has its uses, but it's very situational these days and most modern people will never need it.
- leetcrew 8y agomost people will never need Latin in the sense that they are unlikely to read original works written in Latin unless they become a classics professor. you could say the same thing about most classes in elementary through high school. rarely if ever do I directly apply my knowledge from biology, history, english lit, etc. once we start looking at indirect applications, I think Latin and Greek are easily as useful as any other subject. even if you can't read them fluently, having a firm grasp of grammar and vocab in these languages is a huge advantage when it comes to proficiency in English. complex terminology in other fields becomes much easier to understand when you know the roots.
- chungleong 8y agoIsn't cursive writing still required in certain social situations? I recall having to write a statement in cursive when I took the LSAT. Presumably, so they could verify I was the person who the test if necessary. I kept making mistakes cause I was used to writing Cyrillic in cursive. Muscle memory turned all my p's into n's :-)
- RandomInteger4 8y agoJust vomit out some squiggles. There's no legal requirement in any situation for your signature to correspond to anything.
- chungleong 8y agoI imagine if I were to fail to reproduce my handwriting on demand, the test result would be deemed fraudulent.
- RandomInteger4 8y agoThen learn to make a reproducible squiggle vomit that's unique to you; it's more secure than using the common alphabet of squiggle vomits and wastes less of everyone's time. Alternatively, you could use your knowledge that you were just tested on to construct an argument for why deeming a test fraudulent based on some asinine squiggle vomit system is kind of complete bullshit. I mean, for fork's sake, you are training to be a lawyer after all, so do some got dang lawyering in such an instance.
- braindouche 8y agoI've said for years, the American system gets itself all tangled up because we (want) to teach two entirely different writing systems to children: we start with manuscript (printing) and then once the kids are used to that, we consider slapping them with cursive (and a hideous Palmer hand or a derivative to boot). You want to teach cursive effectively? Drop manuscript training entirely and start kids on the joined-up writing in first grade.
- brianpgordon 8y agoWhy would you pick cursive over print? Making kids practice cursive is insane enough to me; making them only learn cursive is a virtual non sequitur.