4 ms·
Our interest in bailing out Ireland was unusual in the level of exposure our recovering banking sector has to Ireland. Possibly, because of our traditional supp
by notahacker 16y ago
Our interest in bailing out Ireland was unusual in the level of exposure our recovering banking sector has to Ireland. Possibly, because of our traditional support for national sovereignty within the EU, we're even more willing than most countries to do so without compelling the Irish to address their budget imbalance by raising their artificially low taxes. I'm not sure the same self-interest in applies to aiding Portugal though.
The fragmentation of the Euro would undoubtedly have consequences for the UK, but I'm not sure that they would be wholly negative in the shorter term (a bankrupt country unilaterally withdrawing and allowing the Euro to appreciate might even be good for UK exports). Given the parlous state of our own finances, I'm not sure the economic case for contributing to a bailout of other countries is clear cut (given that it's by no means guaranteed to succeed...), and certainly it would be politically disastrous for the British government to commit to any additional spending.
Other countries have more invested in making the Eurozone a success, but ultimately the survival of the Euro depends largely on the continued support of France and Germany as the rest of the Eurozone isn't exactly inundated with money, which leaves inevitably aligns its future very closely with the interests of those countries.
- iuguy 16y agoAs always on HN, the debate is always stimulating and informative compared to other places. I think you're right about Ireland. There's also a lot more in common culturally with Ireland than with Portugal, and while Anglo-Irish history is a tricky subject, I would imagine people would take the concept of helping Ireland more seriously than Portugal. Your point about fragmentation is quite interesting to me. Perhaps if Portugal and Spain were 'encouraged to leave' by the EU that might be a politically bitter pill to swallow, but perhaps a financially acceptable solution. After all, a large part of the Eurozone no longer meets the Copenhagen criteria. Unfortunately neither the EC or EU Parliament seem to have any grounding in reality or rational thought.