18 ms·
How an RC airplane buzzed the Statue of Liberty, with no arrests
- iwr 16y agoRC planes (drones): soon the staple of any serious paparazzi.
- hugh3 16y agoThus, no doubt, spoiling it for everybody as it suddenly becomes illegal to fly a remote-controlled plane without a licence.
- tonycore 16y agoYes.. sadly this will end with regulation- more of it.
- hugh3 16y agoWell, with this kind of thing becoming more popular as it becomes more possible (thanks to improved batteries and cheap small video cameras) it's only a matter of time before it gets regulated. Even if everybody only used them with the best intentions, someday someone's gonna get seriously hurt by getting clobbered on the head by one of these things. Still, for now: awesome video!
- DanielStraight 16y agoIsn't this "what if" thinking the whole problem with, for example, the TSA? Yes, someone will get hurt. Someone may even die. It will be terrible, but it will be an accident. We can't prevent all accidents, nor should we try.
- cma 16y agoWhy is that sad? As these get more and more autonomous they will be capable of targeted assassination. The same hardware accelerated face-recognition chip in your $50 point-and-shoot camera will wind up making point-and-shoot a taboo phrase.
- iwr 16y agoIf those things have enough range, you can just stay indoors, safe from police interference. It would be very difficult to trace unless the cops ran around in triangulation squads. Other ways to do it could be by wireless internet.
- hugh3 16y agoOr they just wait until it lands. Either they catch you picking it up or they confiscate it from you; either way the flight becomes unworthwhile.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- iwr 16y agoIf the contraptions are cheap enough, or the footage valuable enough, there'd be no need to recover it.
- chopsueyar 16y agoLatency.
- daten 16y agoThere are already 802.11 drones with video and cell phones that can act as a wireless hot spot. Combine the two and I don't think latency would be bad enough to prevent you from flying it remotely. I would be more concerned with battery life or dangers of mechanical failure on something large enough to use liquid fuel. [1] http://ardrone.parrot.com/parrot-ar-drone/usa/ http://ardrone.parrot.com/parrot-ar-drone/usa/ [2] http://techcrunch.com/2010/05/13/exclusive-google-to-add-tethering-wifi-hotspot-to-android-2-2-froyo/ http://techcrunch.com/2010/05/13/exclusive-google-to-add-tet...
- chopsueyar 16y agoLoS
- MichaelApproved 16y agoShouldn't a license or some form of registration be required? What if it hits a building or car by mistake? There needs to be some way to trace it to the owner to pay for the damages.
- DanielStraight 16y agoI'm thinking the owner is probably the guy who runs up saying, "I'm sorry, I'm sorry, I'm sorry." Will that always happen? No, of course not. Some people are jerks. Are most people jerks, though? No. The last thing we need is more laws, especially ones that enforce responsibilities most people will take on for themselves.
- MichaelApproved 16y agoThese planes can fly for miles as did this one in the video. The owner isn't going to be running up to anyone after a crash because he'll have to get in a car first and drive over. If your going to be flying something though the air that has a large range and can seriously hurt someone or damage property, it's not to much to ask that it be registered somewhere. Simple registration number so we know who the owner is. Edit: The remote can also lose contact and the owner wouldn't know where the plane crashed to cover property damages.
- jrockway 16y agoBy this logic, people should have registration numbers tattooed on their foreheads, so that if one commits a crime (or just looks at you wrong), we can immediately find it. Makes perfect sense, right?
- mquander 16y agoNo, that doesn't really make any sense, but having people register long-range aircraft makes sense to me.
- bigiain 16y ago
- retube 16y agoNot planes, quadrotors http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MvRTALJp8DM http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MvRTALJp8DM
- dfranke 16y agoIf I had a billion dollars and had paparazzi chasing me, I would love for them to try this so that I'd get to mount an AA gun on my yacht and shoot them down.
- patio11 16y agoI have an unshakeable imagine of an Englishman in a tweed jacket chomping on a cigar holding a shotgun. "Hunting ducks always struck me as uncivilized. Skeet can't dodge. Drones, though, drones are perfect."
- trafficlight 16y agoI picture Jack Nicholson in this role.
- patio11 16y agoJack Nicholson and Dick Cheney, in the buddy movie to end all buddy movies.
- rdtsc 16y agoAll is fun and games until drones start firing back at ya. ... or that just means you are in Pakistan.
- TGJ 16y agoWhy is the guy thanking the TSA? What could they do and why would he even think they could be involved with something like that?
- tzm 16y agoGreat. One more way to strike fear and add to the regulatory glut.
- frisco 16y agoNo. This is the wrong response. Just as the general public shouldn't be afraid of things like this, we shouldn't be afraid of the regulatory response. It is our responsibility to fight that response and preserve fun. If hacker news's response to this video is "great, here comes more regulation", then we have truly lost.
- tzm 16y agoReferring to the suggestive title of the article, which seems to cultivate a negative knee jerk reaction to those outside of Hacker News.
- Estragon 16y agoWhen the cost of these kinds of robot drops by another factor of ten, they're going to have the biggest impact on military security since the invention of nuclear weapons.
- frisco 16y agoWhy? They're already so cheap the military could buy an unlimited number of them. Or because people will use them to remove military security? I don't follow your logic.
- Estragon 16y agoOr because people will use them to remove military security? Exactly. Unless some kind of corresponding defense evolves, they're going to democratize sanitary application of force, which has largely been a privilege of governments until now. (Sanitary to the people ordering it, not to the people directly involved, obviously.) Can you imagine what ethnic cleansing would have looked like in the Balkans if the Serbs had been able to afford thousands of predator-style drones? It won't be long before the cost comes down to the point where they could have.
- krschultz 16y agoNot really, some of the tech on the predator is not cheap. The easy part is making the plane, I'm sure you could rig up a cessna like Hollywood rigs up stunt cars for remote control and you'd have a "UAV" (didn't Iran do that already?). The guided missiles, the communications, the optics and sensors, those are the hard parts. I honestly think a bunch of boots on the ground with rifles is the scariest way to do ethnic cleansing, if you just want to level houses you have artillery and tanks too. The predator is good for surgical strikes and intelligence, which a lot of enemies really don't care about.
- trunnell 16y agoI don't think it's the cost of the plane that is the limiting factor here. You might be underestimating the difference between this type of R/C plane and a military-class drone like a Predator. One of the more difficult challenges to overcome is the range of the communication link between the pilot and the plane. This guy demonstrated a range of mile or so. For many of the kinds of military uses that would have the "big impact" you're talking about, the plane would need over-the-horizon range-- which as a practical matter would mean satellite-based comm. So basically you need satellite launch capability to support this kind of project. The cost of that would be a limiting factor.
- yawniek 16y agoit was also featured on msnbc: http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/21134540/vp/40492187#40492187 http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/21134540/vp/40492187#40492187
- seliopou 16y agoAbout two years ago I lived in Long Island City, around Vernon Boulevard and 44th Drive. At least a couple times a week I'd see an RC plane doing circles around the neighborhood and I always wondered who was controlling it and for what purpose. Now I know.
- hedgehog 16y agoThis guy's Vimeo account has a bunch of these videos. Most of them look like they're shot up mountains in western Europe (Austria?). http://vimeo.com/trappy/videos http://vimeo.com/trappy/videos If you're going to watch one: http://vimeo.com/16604842 http://vimeo.com/16604842 In the downhill sections he is turning off the motor and gliding at about 150 km/h.
- dotBen 16y agoSo having watched the video you suggested, and remembered the music on the original video I immediately recalled this: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I4U6T_BB1N8 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I4U6T_BB1N8 These guys do the same close-proximity flying in Alps, but in wingsuits. If you only watch a bit of it, skip to 3:05 and compare to the vimeo video!
- hedgehog 16y agoThat is quite beautiful.
- sbierwagen 16y agoNow he just needs two cameras, for a stereoscopic display.If Avatar and HTTYD told us anything, it's that the killer app of 3D cinema is flying sequences.
- duffbeer703 16y agoThese sorts of unauthorized flights, combined with model rockets from hobby stores and household cleaners could have created a terrorist nightmare. Where are the feds?
- blhack 16y agoA few months ago, the idea that my [hacker] roomate and I were spitballing around was a drone that could fly from my house in Phoenix, to MIT's campus in Massachusetts. The joke was that we both daydreamed about being able to go to school there, and building a drone that could go across the country would be cool enough to get their attention. They'd have to admit us! This was the type of thing that we would probably never, ever do, but sitting around drinking beer and talking about how you could do it was still a fun time. Then the joke got smaller. My mom makes the best chocolate chip cookies in the world. Trouble is that she lives an hour away. How cool would it be to have a cookie delivery robot? Build a plane that can fly across Phoenix to my Mom's house, pick up some cookies, then fly back? Cookie robot sounds almost feasible. The most discouraging thing was to learn that if we even tried this, we would probably end up in jail. Flying an unmanned model plane like that is very, very, very, very illegal. There are safety concerns, you see. It's possible to get drones certified as legal by the FAA, but it requires either sponsorship by a University (Roomate graduated, I dropped out, so that is out of the question), or sponsorship by a defense-contractor. I understand the safety concerns. The reason that the FAA calls this illegal is because they don't want unmanned model planes wandering into controlled airspace, or crashing and starting a fire or something. I get that. But I understand the safety concerns. Over half of the beers were consumed while having conversations about failsafe mechanisms to SCRAM the thing if it lost radio contact. This is very immature of me, I know, but it's still frustrating. It's frustrating that this [TFA] is newsworthy because the person who built it wasn't arrested. Arrested? How did we get to this point where, if you tell me a story about somebody flying a model plane around the statue of liberty, my first reaction is that he is probably locked in an interrogation room somewhere being "questioned"? Does stuff like this put people at danger? Yes. Having a 10-20 pound chunk of couregated plastic and balsa wood crash into the street is dangerous. Should the person be thrown in jail? I don't know, should the people who drive 4000 guided hunks of steel around populated areas while texting and adjusting their radio knobs be thrown in jail? Is my cookie robot really more dangerous than my 4200 low-speed, guided battering-ram called "Jeep"?
- pyre 16y agoIt just comes down to entrenchment and popular opinion. Much in the same vein, alcohol and tobacco "aren't drugs," but pot and 'shrooms are.
- zavulon 16y agoThe video is missing how the plane itself looks like. Otherwise, amazing!!
- stcredzero 16y agoMy immediate thought: filming POV shots for superhero movies just got a whole lot cheaper. Thought #2: it's only a matter of time before someone tries to use such a setup to kill someone using a small anti-personnel explosive delivered by such a device.
- kragen 16y agoArt Vanden Berg launched an autonomous glider up to where the sky is black in the daytime, six [edit: five] times, back in 2002: http://members.shaw.ca/sonde/ http://members.shaw.ca/sonde/ He wrote all the software (avionics, telemetry, and ground support) himself. It maintained a telemetry link during most of each flight, and landed successfully five [edit: four] times, I think most of them on autopilot. Around that time, Jef Raskin wrote a thought-provoking piece on the security implications of UAVs such as Laima. I can't find it on Raskin's site anymore, but here's a mirror: http://allnurses-central.com/world-news-current/next-time-can-37112.html http://allnurses-central.com/world-news-current/next-time-ca... There's a site about building amateur autonomous UAVs run by a Wired editor, which nevertheless seems to have relatively reliable information. Disturbingly, it has a diagram of a Predator on the front page: http://diydrones.com/ http://diydrones.com/ These guys are doing a bunch of stuff with kites and balloons as well, specifically to make maps available. Although some jurisdictions (like China) place restrictions on such activities, they seem to be doing a lot of good, and so far nobody's ended up in jail: http://grassrootsmapping.org/ http://grassrootsmapping.org/ In 2008, someone used a small flying dildo helicopter to make a political statement against Garry Kasparov (warning, includes photos of a flying dildo): http://hackaday.com/2008/05/19/flying-rc-penis-violates-chessmasters-airspace/ http://hackaday.com/2008/05/19/flying-rc-penis-violates-ches... The first writing I recall reading about this issue was "Danny Dunn, Invisible Boy", published in 1974; it mostly discussed the use of teleoperated UAVs for spying, not violence: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Danny_Dunn,_Invisible_Boy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Danny_Dunn,_Invisible_Boy I think the concerns about terrorism are overblown. The world will never be perfectly safe, and people will keep on using violence against each other for quite a while yet, but fragile UAVs don't seem like they'll be a particularly big force multiplier as weapons. The concerns about privacy are probably much more significant.
- wmf 16y agoI see a lot of comments here about (autonomous) drones, but this video was made with old-fashioned remote control. The laws are different. I think the only novel aspects of attaching a camera to an RC vehicle are (1) the fact that cameras are now cheap enough that you don't care if it gets destroyed in a crash, and (2) OMG terrorism.
- rebooter 16y agoThese people need to get into a LOT of trouble. This is not legal, and for good reason. I say this from the perspective of having designed, built and flown RC fixed-wing and helicopters for well over twenty years. As neat and sophisticated as they might look, these things are still toys. They are not built to the same standards as real aircraft. Single failure modes abound and they are, in most cases, catastrophic. I have seen model airplanes loose a horizontal stabilizer in flight for no apparent good reason. Or simply fall out of the sky like a brick when one of the cheap electronic parts inside fails. Figure out the kinetic energy of a 8 to 10 pound object travelling at 100+ miles per hour to understand the lethality potential. The airspace he covered is flown by full-scale aircraft. Imagine being a tourist taking one of those NYC helicopter flights (done that) only to plummet to your death because some a-hole decided it was OK to take his $300 toy on a joy flight. Beyond, that, imagine if this was, in fact, legal. Would you like to see 100 of these things flying without control around an airspace such as NYC? Bad idea. They need to get into a LOT of trouble. This is definitely not something anyone should emulate or replicate. It will ruin the model aircraft hobby in the US forever.
- scottbessler 16y agoI've not seen anything that said RC flight is illegal in controlled airspace, do you have a link showing this?
- rebooter 16y agoOperation of UAV's is most definitely regulated by the FAA, and for good reason. Per FAA rules, the fellow in question needed to follow full-scale airframe and operator certification (UAV operator), carry appropriate insurance and observe airspace restrictions per the FAA. If you are interested search the FAA site and regs. As far as him having checked for flights before launching: What a lame joke! I have flown in a full scale helicopter in that airspace, around the Statute of Liberty, etc.. The pilots are in constant communication and visually scan the airspace for potential danger. They can't and don't do whatever the heck they want. I am one of those people who doesn't need a law to understand that something should not be done just 'cause you can. It is dumb, stupid, moronic and dangerous to fly an RC plane over, around, close to people, buildings, bridges and small farm animals. You could kill people. No law needed in order to understand the reasons this is so. But they are there for those who lack common sense. This guy is a moron. Certifiable. Sorry, no other way to put it.
- dotBen 16y agoDoes anyone know how the police found him? (The Ars post mentions the police visited him while he was doing it, and you can see the police at the end of the video) Someone phones in to 911 an RC Plane buzzing buildings, etc... but with the tools at the police's disposal, how would they have found where he was?
- fleitz 16y agoThey probably took the address from the caller and looked for the plane near there. Once finding it, they likely looked around the area for a guy with an RC remote. Of course they could have also used a radio direction finder.
- dotBen 16y agoHmm but he was flying over a huge area - from Brooklyn Bridge, Statue of Liberty, apartment buildings on the waters-edge, etc. I'm wondering if they used radio direction finder - but a) would they have that equipment to hand and b) how would they know what frequency to be looking on?
- angusgr 16y agoHe had a fairly large antenna set up on a large stand next to him, and presumably the PoV headset on and a controller and things like that. If a police car drove by, I think they'd consider it worth asking him what he was doing. I say asking, not freaking out over, because there is an important difference.