4 ms·
>> Chris Adzima, senior information systems analyst for the Washington County Sheriff’s Office in Oregon, said the agency uses Amazon’s Rekognition to identify
by YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago
>> Chris Adzima, senior information systems analyst for the Washington County Sheriff’s Office in Oregon, said the agency uses Amazon’s Rekognition to identify the most likely matches among its collection of roughly 350,000 mug shots. But because a human makes the final decision, “the bias of that computer system is not transferred over into any results or any action taken,” Adzima said.
The gentleman is saying that the system selects a small subset of the 350,000 mugshots, but because a human selects one mugshot from this small subset, there is no bias.
That just makes no sense.
[edited to remove stronger language]
- Mirioron 8y agoIt does make some sense. Yes, technically, the bias is still there, but it's lower. Getting some accuracy on image detection isn't that difficult, but making it more and more accurate is. Going from 50% accuracy to 51% is much easier than 98% to 99%. Of course, with the error rates reported on certain groups a human making the final decision is not enough.
- Retric 8y agoThe problem is a human would at best reduce but not eliminate the bias. Let’s assume the photo was not a match for the database. Now a human doing the final step is essentially pick a random face from a biased sample. Worse, people are really bad about assuming whatever option they are considering to be far more likely than the base rate. Read up on an random obscure disease and suddenly you start thinking it’s a real risk. Sadly, police do the same thing with criminal suspects resulting in innocent people in prison.