2 ms·
IANAL - But I think it depends on how much it is a "translation", and how much it is a reimplementation of an identical algorithm. As I understand it copyright
by gpm 8y ago
IANAL - But I think it depends on how much it is a "translation", and how much it is a reimplementation of an identical algorithm.
As I understand it copyright doesn't apply to the algorithm. It does apply to things like code organization, variable naming, and comments.
- UncleEntity 8y ago> Original elisp algorithm. While using the original elisp source as a guideline might result in less idiomatic Rust code... Seems to be a pretty direct translation (without reading the sources of both). Now, if they took the original source and used it to implement a grammar then based the rust code off said grammar they might have a case -- which, I believe, is what a "clean room" implementation would do, preferably with two different people doing either task. IMHO this is a clear copyright violation else you could just "reimplement" your way out of any license.
- gpm 8y agoAIUI clean room implementation isn't required, just good practice to avoid - Accidentally copying copyrighted material (past what fair use allows) - Expensive lawsuits where you have to actually argue that "no we didn't copy copyrighted elements" We're talking about two open source projects here, the latter anyways doesn't really matter.