6 ms·
> As the Mercatus Center noted last year, by implementing a Medicare for All system, the US could insure 30 million more people, provide dental, vision, and hea
by AnthonyMouse 8y ago
> As the Mercatus Center noted last year, by implementing a Medicare for All system, the US could insure 30 million more people, provide dental, vision, and hearing coverage to everyone, and virtually eliminate out-of-pocket expenses, all while saving $2 trillion over the first decade of implementation.
This is assuming Medicare would have the same cost structure if it insured everyone that it does right now, which is incorrect because Medicare is currently being subsidized by private insurance.
In order to make healthcare in the US cost less, something that is currently being paid for has got to go away. That isn't primarily "insurance company profits" or anything like that. The profits are a single digit percentage of the premiums.
The costs come from things like the extraordinarily high cost of getting FDA approvals reducing competition between pharma companies, doctors choosing unnecessary tests for liability reasons and patients preferring them when someone else is paying for them and things of that nature. It is not clear how Medicare would change any of that, given that it currently doesn't solve them even for existing Medicare patients, it just pays below its share of the fixed costs and lets private insurance pick up the difference.
You have to actually get the costs down. In theory you could just declare by fiat that you aren't going to pay as much, which would cause something to be cut, but not the inefficiencies that the law continues to require. A "solution" that causes good things to be cut so that existing wasteful things will still fit into the budget is not very good.
- yourbandsucks 8y agoHealth insurance takings don't have to be 'profits' to be waste. How much unnecessary work happens around crazy billing systems and arguing over who pays what? Those people all draw salaries.
- StephenAmar 8y agoThis is the core problem. I'm all for Medicare for all, but what to do with the many physician assistants, nurses, billing specialists that the US is employing and promoting as a middle class career as we speak. These people will not just stay silent when they become unemployed because practitioners can't afford to keep them. You need retraining programs (in what? Beats me ...), fund unemployment insurance ... The point is that things don't happen in a vacuum.
- yourbandsucks 8y agoKeep the PAs and nurses, lose the billing specialists. Seems like a really clear cut call to me. I know they're people, maybe we could have retraining programs, but it's not like private capital says "what about the people?" when trimming the redundant.
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoYou're looking at it backwards. We, as a society, can stop wasting people on this nonsense, and find something worthwhile for them to do. (Yes, and we have some responsibility to make it possible for them to find a new way to earn a living, training them if needed.)
- StephenAmar 8y agoAnecdotally, I see the situation in France (I'm from there). Unemployment is always high. People have great healthcare, but they are still struggling with mininum income service jobs. They won't be ruined by a cancer diagnosis though. I don't think any western countries has figured out how to expand the middle class in recent times without heavy subsidies (in the US, we are effectively subsidizing those jobs with our high costs)
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoExcept that Medicare is "insurance" and correspondingly still has insurance paperwork.
- yourbandsucks 8y agoWayyyy simpler, and it's only one system instead of many conflicting ones. Medicare and SS move money around much more efficiently than any private system in terms of overhead. Sometimes innovation is a downside.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> Wayyyy simpler, and it's only one system instead of many conflicting ones. It seems like the real problem is that "insurance" has something to do with <$1000 bills to begin with. The overhead is negligible if the bill is going to be large enough to actually require being insured against, but then we use "insurance" for routine care that wouldn't otherwise be expensive enough to justify it and then no surprise there is unnecessary overhead. > Medicare and SS move money around much more efficiently than any private system in terms of overhead. They make the same argument about the IRS. Look how much money it "brings in" compared to the number of people it employees. Very "efficient" -- except that the money they take in was already the taxpayer's to begin with, so moving it around is net of zero and the only thing there is cost. And they don't count the overhead on the taxpayer's side of doing the paperwork either. It's the same here. Most of the insurance paperwork is to prevent insurance fraud and determine coverage and prevent unnecessary procedures. It's not more efficient to pay for more unnecessary procedures and lose more money to fraud. And you're still not going to beat the overhead of the patient going in for a $100 procedure, paying $100 for it, and never involving a third party to the transaction at all.
- yourbandsucks 8y agoDude, look at the topline numbers. They are completely fucked. Meanwhile, 10/10 developed nation socialist healthcare systems are comparatively cheaper and better. I'm not super impressed by well-written rationalizations in light of those facts.
- tokyodude 8y agowell in some countries they don't allow prices that high for services and drugs. no idea what problems that caused but ATM prices charged for various services and drugs in the USA are 3x to 10x some other countries
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> well in some countries they don't allow prices that high for services and drugs. no idea what problems that caused but ATM prices charged for various services and drugs in the USA are 3x to 10x some other countries The problem it caused is that there is correspondingly less drug R&D and more people die world-wide because they're not paying their share of the research costs.
- deogeo 8y agoGiven that pharmaceutical companies spend more on marketing than they do on R&D [1], isn't it more accurate to say that the rest of the world isn't paying their share of drug ads? How small would the fraction of revenue pharma spends on R&D for new drugs (excluding generics, which the analysis in [1] doesn't) before higher prices are no longer justified? [1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2015/02/11/big-pharmaceutical-companies-are-spending-far-more-on-marketing-than-research/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2015/02/11/big-p...
- AnthonyMouse 8y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19659888 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19659888
- deogeo 8y ago> marketing increases the number of "customers" by more than the cost of the marketing (or why do it?), and the extra money is what both encourages and pays for more R&D. Does it increase the number, or does it just reallocate customers from one company to another? And I'll repeat my question - how high do drug prices have to get, before further increases can no longer be justified because some scrap of the revenue goes towards R&D?
- maxxxxx 8y ago" it just pays below its share of the fixed costs and lets private insurance pick up the difference." Is that actually true? I always hear that line but nobody every backs it up with data. If Medicare is losing money for hospitals why do they still take it?
- ikeboy 8y agoThere are citations in the Mercatus paper to government data showing this. Medicare generally pays below cost. > If Medicare is losing money for hospitals why do they still take it? Many have stopped. The ones that do presumably are getting paid above marginal cost, but that doesn't mean they're getting paid above average total cost.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> Is that actually true? I always hear that line but nobody every backs it up with data. If Medicare is losing money for hospitals why do they still take it? Fixed costs vs. variable costs. It costs a million dollars to have a hospital, then there is a further $250 marginal cost to treat another patient. If there are 2000 patients then the average patient has to be charged $750 ($250 + $1M/2000) to cover costs. If Medicare says $500 or GFTO then $500 is more than $250 and they "make" $250 by accepting Medicare, but if they received that much from the average patient they wouldn't cover their costs.
- maxxxxx 8y agoAt a minimum a lot of money would be saved by standardized billing practices and costs. If Medicare pays too little then reimbursement could be adjusted. It would lead to more transparency and less bureaucracy. I think that’s how it works in Germany. There are different insurers but they operate on a set of standards. It’s nuts that in the US every insurance negotiates separately with each provider. It’s extremely inefficient and also makes it basically impossible for the patient to do any price shopping.
- testpostpls 8y agoGermany saves money by paying doctors $70k/yr. There isn’t a clever, low-impact policy shift that’ll save a ton of money in the US. Something really big has to give.
- ZhuanXia 8y agoDon't forget the doctor's guild limiting supply of doctors.
- grey-area 8y agoThis is assuming Medicare would have the same cost structure if it insured everyone that it does right now, which is incorrect because Medicare is currently being subsidized by private insurance. No, it's assuming that the successful outcomes and cost-benefits of single-payer, as proven throughout the world, can also be applied to the US.
- asark 8y agoAt this point the fact that the whole friggin' rest of the OECD states have managed to come up with something less-broken and less expensive than what we do, and that AFAIK even the most "free market" and incomparable to ours demographically and geographically (e.g. Singapore) have done this with price controls and a "public option" or similar, is such easy-to-come-by and oft-repeated info that "gee I just don't know how this could work in the US" or "more government intervention can't possibly fix anything" can't be charitably interpreted. It's concern trolling or gross ignorance. Period. We've been talking about this for decades. The data are there. They're not hidden. It's not theoretical. Pick a demonstrated-to-work system and do it.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- narrator 8y agoSingapore's system is not even single payer. Why is the only choice single payer or nothing? Also, if Americans could import drugs from abroad, that would greatly lower health care costs as the overseas drugs are made by the same manufacturer and are sold at 1/10th the price in India and elsewhere.
- deogeo 8y ago> if Americans could import drugs from abroad Free trade for me, not for thee.
- asark 8y agoYeah, there are plenty of non-single-payer ones that work. Probably it'd be safer to pick a system that works for a country more similar to ours (Canada, Australia, even France or Germany) but a Swiss or maybe Singaporean system would likely still be better than what we're doing. Singapore's odd and can do to-us-crazy (that is, restrictive) stuff to improve public health if they need to to keep costs down, so I'd hesitate to advance that as the best choice, but our system is so very bad that it'd probably still be better than sticking with what we're doing. Price controls, public option, everyone must get insurance. Maybe outlaw for-profit health insurance. Those seem to be the basic, minimum common factors that make these suck less than ours, if you don't want to go single-payer or nationalized.
- Youden 8y ago> In order to make healthcare in the US cost less, something that is currently being paid for has got to go away. This is some super back of the napkin stuff. I'm just looking at each aspect of the healthcare industry and estimating how much inefficiency (profit) there is to eliminate by looking at the margins of the largest player in that industry. Anthem financials: https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/antm/financials/ https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/antm/financials/ - $20B profit on $92B revenue. Assuming this is roughly the same as other insurance providers in the $967B industry, there's ~$200B in savings. Pfizer financials: https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/PFE/financials/ https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/PFE/financials/ - $42B profit on $53B revenue. The pharmaceutical industry in the US is $935B so there's another ~$750B in savings. We're at $950B now. HCA healthcare (largest hospital system in the US): https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/HCA/financials/ https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/HCA/financials/ - $18B profit on $47B revenue. Hospitals are also at ~$1T, so there's another $380B in savings. So there's $1.2T in savings. There are surely other parts of the US healthcare industry I'm missing but there's also a lot to be saved by vertically integrating everything.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> Anthem financials: https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/antm/financials/ https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/antm/financials/ - $20B profit on $92B revenue. Assuming this is roughly the same as other insurance providers in the $967B industry, there's ~$200B in savings. Anthem is an HMO, not "just" an insurance company. They tend to make higher margins specifically because they're more cost efficient and correspondingly have more profit, so extrapolating from that is somewhat misleading. But even using your numbers, $200B is not "the problem" here -- that's around 5% of the money being spent, and because of the nature of insurance tends to scale down with other costs and remain at the same percentage of the then lower absolute costs when other costs are reduced. > Pfizer financials: https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/PFE/financials/ https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/PFE/financials/ - $42B profit on $53B revenue. The pharmaceutical industry in the US is $935B so there's another ~$750B in savings. We're at $950B now. People still want Lipitor and Zoloft, so that's all still there unless you regulate drug prices, which you can do or not independent of single payer (but that has its own problems). And you can't just write off all profits as "we don't need that let's get rid of it" -- it's just measuring risk adjusted reward on capital. To have a hospital you have to put down millions of dollars to buy MRI machines and everything else, which then gets paid back with interest over a period of years. If it's private that comes from the investors and then the "profit" is their interest on the investment. Making the hospital "public" doesn't deprive you of the need to raise money to pay for equipment and then pay interest on it, unless you're going to pay 100% of the costs up front out of taxes in year zero -- and deprive the taxpayers of the interest they would have collected on the same money in the meantime. TANSTAAFL.
- mahgnous 8y agoAlso you have a trillion dollar revenue insurance industry that is going to fight whatever it is tooth and nail cause it doesn't want to just disappear.
- bradleyjg 8y agoThe costs come from things like the extraordinarily high cost of getting FDA approvals reducing competition between pharma companies, doctors choosing unnecessary tests for liability reasons and patients preferring them when someone else is paying for them and things of that nature. You missed the biggest one: massively overcompensated specialty physicians. We can expect price controls to reduce that. And since there is currently a massive surplus of qualified applicants to medical schools, we shouldn't expect shortages either.
- specialist 8y ago"...Medicare is currently being subsidized by private insurance." Did you mean "supplemented"?