9 ms·
They probably didn’t talk my elderly aunt, who paid a similar sum with her $1,100/mo social security and was able to stay in her community, parish and close to
by Spooky23 8y ago
They probably didn’t talk my elderly aunt, who paid a similar sum with her $1,100/mo social security and was able to stay in her community, parish and close to loved ones.
- mikeash 8y agoThere must be better ways to accomplish this that don’t result in valuable apartments sitting empty.
- eecc 8y agoValuable? To whom, and for what reasons?
- mikeash 8y agoValuable to people who want a place to live. The reason is that people need shelter.
- coldtea 8y agoPeople also need their shelter to be cheap once they've found it, and rent control allows for that. Without rent control you just have the market force people into musical chairs for highest bidders, for the benefits of the landlords.
- mikeash 8y agoAnd we’re back to my original comment: there must be a better way to accomplish this.
- njepa 8y agoIf we conclude that people should have affordable and predictable rent it is hard to make rent control the problem. While not adjusting rent for inflation and upkeep seems counterproductive, someone occupying an apartment at a low margin is only really a problem if we can't produce more apartments, or more opportunities, at the same price. The housing market cannot increase forever. You either end up with massive inflation or massive inequality. The few good ideas seem to essentially be to treat housing as infrastructure. Of course building infrastructure is a problem in itself for many countries.
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoWho should have affordable and predictable rent? Everybody? We're not getting that from rent control, because it only applies to a subset. Those who need it? We're not getting that from rent control, either, because many people suffer from high rent who don't have a rent-controlled apartment. Some of this may be due to those who don't need it getting it, but I suspect the numbers of such cases aren't enough to account for all those who need it who don't get it. > someone occupying an apartment at a low margin is only really a problem if we can't produce more apartments, or more opportunities, at the same price. That's exactly the problem with rent control. Let's say that there are a shortage of apartments for $100/month in NYC. Who is going to try to build more apartments in NYC for $100/month? Anybody who tries is going to lose their shirt. We can't produce them at that price. Rent control doesn't make that problem go away.
- njepa 8y ago> We can't produce them at that price. $100 per month isn't realistic, $500 might be. While construction costs do rise, you are mostly paying for the exclusivity. "High-rise apartment buildings cost an average $302 per square foot." https://therealdeal.com/2018/05/15/surprise-nyc-remains-most-expensive-place-to-build-in-the-world-report/ https://therealdeal.com/2018/05/15/surprise-nyc-remains-most...
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoSo, $151,000 per 600-square-foot apartment. If the loan for the building costs was at 5%, the interest cost is $7500 a year, or $629/month. That's not counting paying back principle, or maintenance. You might be able to do it for $800/month, though.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- door5 8y agoTrue -- vastly expanding public housing, with the goal of eventually eliminating private housing. Housing should be a public good, not a commodity. Until then, rent control is a good way of minimizing the extent to which landlords exploit their tenants.
- alexis_fr 8y agoFood should be public good, then.
- door5 8y agoAlso true.
- tehjoker 8y agohttps://www.mintpressnews.com/empty-homes-outnumber-the-homeless-6-to-1-so-why-not-give-them-homes/207194/ https://www.mintpressnews.com/empty-homes-outnumber-the-home...
- pariahHN 8y agoThe fundamentals of life in general should trend towards not being commodities - it should get easier over time for people to do things themselves, instead of there being more things someone has to pay for.
- Spooky23 8y agoPretty easy. Just tax the difference between market rate and actual rate, and apply a means test to it. The mostly mythical Rich folk collecting cheap apartments will go away quickly.
- etrautmann 8y agoDoesn’t this directly defeat the rent control?
- Spooky23 8y agoNo, just phase it in at some income level. We tax normal people on a similar basis — if you settle a debt, you’ll get a 1099 for whatever was written off and must pay tax unless you are insolvent.
- segmondy 8y agoWhat if you were the owner of the building?
- baron816 8y agoYes, good for people who get rent control. Bad for everyone else.
- Kiro 8y agoHow is it bad for society?
- luminaobscura 8y agoit limits the supply of apartments to the market, which drives up prices.
- paulddraper 8y agoThey probably didn't talk to her. But that doesn't really change things, does it? Prices completely out of wack with market.
- jaredklewis 8y agoThis is a great outcome for your aunt. I'm glad for her. But my objection to rent control has always been that it is wealth distribution by lottery. The wealth is not redistributed based on need or any other principle. It is totally arbitrary. Did your apartment become rent controlled or were you born into a rent controlled apartment? Congratulations, you get to live in a highly desirable area at below market rates. Didn't get so lucky? Well, sucks to be you. Most lower class people don't receive housing assistance of any kind. Why should a random selection of people (from all tax brackets) get rent control? If your aunt had won the lottery, that would also be a good outcome for her. But I don't think it then follows that the lottery is a progressive social policy.
- Spooky23 8y agoRead “The Death and Life of Great American Cities” — community is about people. Everything is a lottery. My parents bought a house in a marginal neighborhood in NYC for $20k in the 70s and made a 100x return at retirement time. By accident of birth, I bought a beautiful house in a different place in the 2000s that hasn’t gained much value. Renters on the other hand always get screwed as capital concentrates and rent is pushed up. Even in my case where I’m not making money, my expenses are flat and equity growing. That’s not an option today for most people. In my aunts case, she lived into her late 80s independently. If she had lived in a typical suburban environment, she would have almost certainly been in a nursing facility and would have incurred 10x higher taxpayer costs and a much lower quality of life.
- twiceaday 8y agoYou and your parents saved up a lot of money and made an explicit choice as to how to invest it. That's not the same as doing absolutely nothing and waking up to an email that your apartment is now rent controlled. > Renters on the other hand always get screwed as capital concentrates and rent is pushed up. You seem to have a very strong pro-housing bias. Here you imply that renters are people who cannot afford to buy a house. There are other ways to invest, right? Those investments can cover increasing rents and even beat real-estate investing.
- macspoofing 8y agoA disastrous policy is still a disastrous policy even if there are people like your elderly aunt who derive great benefits from it.