10 ms·
The New York Times sells premium ads based on how an article makes you feel
- spectramax 8y agoWhy is the advertisement industry so sleezy and disgusting? Aren’t there any sensible ways of putting your product or service out there without insane advertisement strategies that invade privacy, cross ethical boundaries and sometimes, literally illegal? Advertisement is why we have privacy issues (the other being governments spying on their people) and giant corporations based on targeted advertisement business model. It’s sickening and people working in this profession should be ashamed of themselves. Not to mention all the psychological tricks that go into the “smell” of the store, deluding people into buying and then underdelivering, buy one get one free, sales!!! sales!!! sales!!!, 20% off if you sign up for a store credit card, etc. what happened to ethics and honesty in doing business? There has to be a more sensible way? Word of mouth, magazines, banners, trade shows, demos, putting product on the shelf, etc aren’t good enough? I am not a sales man but boy I despise that whole industry.
- kosei 8y agoIs this really more slimy than targeted ads? At least this is based on the content, not the person's information who is browsing it.
- rbinv 8y agoCompetition. Other companies do shady stuff (that works), so you "have to," too.
- thomasahle 8y agoOne of the dead comments in this thread calls for "criminalizing advertising". I am quite positive to this idea myself. Does advertising really do anything positive to the economy and the world? Doesn't the paradox of advertising already prove that it is at best unnecessary? Recently however I read about the time in the middle ages when guilts had forbidden advertisement. They took this to such a degree, that if a merchant would cough while a potential customer was walking nearby, the other merchants would accuse him/her of trying to catch the attention of the passer-by. Perhaps the reason we allow advertisement is just that we don't know how to get rid of it. However, then we should certainly try to regulate it as much as possible; make rules limiting it to the tolerable and perhaps undamaging. Unfortunately, it may be that so many industries now depend on selling adverts, that limiting it in any meaningful degree would be very hard politically.
- rbinv 8y agoAds do help with discovery. But most of it is exploitation of psychological shortcomings and biases.
- chillacy 8y agoAnd as formal ads get phased out, we're starting to see native ads more and more on youtube. There are plenty that are disclosed but there are plenty which are not.
- thomasahle 8y agoThe unregulated ones are already illegal though.
- soared 8y agoYou work for a company that makes chatbots, virtual agents, a personalization engine, and analytics. How do you hold such an extreme opinion while contributing to it every single day? Advertising literally pays your salary.
- themacguffinman 8y agoBanning advertisement is fundamentally impossible in a free society because advertising is speech. You can't stop people from persuading other people. You can't realistically ban paid advertisement either, that just pushes it underground because it's so valuable that people will find a way to pay for it anyway. What you're asking for is a society free of financially-motivated influence, and I don't think that has/can/will ever exist. Even if you could get rid of advertising, that just cedes control of advertising to random natural factors like geography or chance. It's not clear to me how that's a better state of affairs.
- thomasahle 8y agoThe alternative wouldn't be chance. In the ideal world we would have unbiased reviews to guide us. I very much agree with you however. We can't ban it. It just practically isn't possible. We should be able to regulate it though.
- mikeash 8y agoAll industry will be sleazy and disgusting if it pays to be that way. If giving kids cancer meant they could make an extra dollar, they’d do it. (And there are plenty of examples of other industries doing exactly that.) The only way to put a stop to it is to make it unprofitable.
- solipsism 8y agoThere was a story a few years ago about a girl scout who found that she could be incredibly successful by setting up shop outside marijuana stores. From one angle, this girl is giving the customer what they want. It's a win-win. From another angle, this girl is using psychological tricks to exploit her customers to convince them to buy eat high-fat high-sugar cookies. If it were easy to come up with a clear boundary between ethical and unethical advertising that most people agreed with, I believe we would do it. There has to be a more sensible way? Like what? If you were to put forth a recommendation it actually seemed like it could work, that would be something people could go forward with. Short of that, you're asking companies to not take advantage of legal methods that their competitors surely will take advantage of.
- pgodzin 8y agoBut there are no privacy concerns in this case. The ad placement is completely contextual based on content, not based on viewer. They just trained a model to learn what sentiment an article would elicit and allows advertisers to target based on that. This seems like the best case for advertisements for anyone concerned with privacy and targeting.
- nicky0 8y agoWhat's slimy and dishonest about having a store that smells nice? Do you object to cleanliness and a pleasant temperature too?
- OnlyRepliesToBS 8y agocriminalize advertising
- tehjoker 8y ago"The offering also includes “neutrality targeting”: that is, isolating upsetting stories that could decrease receptivity to ad messages — placements to be avoided." In a news environment driven by ad revenues, expect the news to avoid hard hitting stories that make you feel bad. Shame and anger are emotions that cause change -- they don't sell consumer products well. Chipper stories are the order of the day, never mind the complete capture of the information system by corporations, government elites, and the rich generally.
- matt4077 8y agoYou should maybe coordinate with the other popular conspiracy theory, namely that „the media“ is driving outrage because it sells so well.
- jammygit 8y agoCan you call it a conspiracy? Its more of a temptation combined with financial risks for not doing it
- coldtea 8y agoOr the naive, starry eyed, theory (only upper middle class Americans could ever be sold) that there are no conspiracies. In other words, that whenever big private interests have a chance to make more profit by collusion, alignment, and covert action, they never do...
- tzs 8y agoNews environments have been driven by ad revenue for over a century. Serious newspapers address this by a Chinese wall between editorial and advertising departments [1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_wall#Journalism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_wall#Journalism
- coldtea 8y agoAnd everybody who has worked in/around journalism and advertising knows that this "chinese wall" was already quite BS in the 80s, and is very much so now (and getting worse), even in the most "serious" of newspapers...
- spyspy 8y agoHere's a video from one of the data scientists who worked on the project explaining the science behind it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sVzZmNxmWko https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sVzZmNxmWko
- matt4077 8y agoIt would seem that such ad placement, based only on content and not the reader, is exactly what privacy advocates have been clamoring for. I know the mention of emotions creeps people out. But it’s probably the only salient connection a general interest publisher such as the Times can offer advertisers. Very few of their articles mention any product, product category, or really any factual nexus to anything somebody might want to sell.
- cirgue 8y agoThis sets up a horrifying set of perverse incentives for journalists. This is not to say that the set of incentives facing journalism today isn't already pretty bad, but this forces entities like the NYT further onto a path of convergent evolution with the National Enquirer.
- krastanov 8y agoThe journalists I know describe something they call a "firewall". Supposedly the business staff and the journalists simply do not communicate except for very formalized channels. At some places they are not permitted to walk in on each other's floors/buildings. From personal observations, it seems they usually adhere to the firewall.
- 52-6F-62 8y agoI’ve worked closely with media, and this is something I’ve witnessed as well. Where many people like to propose that journalists and editors are steered by the business and sales staff-my own experience couldn’t be further from the truth. I can’t speak for less reputable outlets. The journalistic outlets I’ve worked with have been very dedicated to their own voice—and passionately so.
- kortilla 8y agoThis works for obvious direct pressure, but there is still pressure in that they work for the same entity. A nytimes journalist wants the paper to do well and as long as that journalist knows how the paper makes money, there will be pressure mentally to support that.
- c13u 8y agoIs this one of those instances where regulatory laws would help? Something like requiring publishers to place a notice saying, "This article typically invokes hope. The ads shown on this page utilize this tendency". These premium ads look like the logical progression of content-based advertising. The only slimy thing is them pretending to be randomly placed.
- soared 8y agoMost respectable brands conform to AdChoices policies. If you click the little blue triangle on an ad it will usually tell you how an ad was targeted to you.
- cs702 8y agoBelow is the list of feelings, which, according to the article, the NYT is now predicting with ML models trained on a proprietary dataset collected internally from a sample of articles shown to a sample of readers. I've marked positive feelings with `(+)`, negative feelings with `(-)`, and feelings which could be viewed one way or another, depending on context, with `( )`. Remarkably, a majority of these feelings are positive, so this advertising initiative, which has been successful at increasing per-ad revenues by as much as 80%, is creating a financial incentive for the NYT to produce content that generates positive feelings in readers! On its face, this is shocking to me. I would have never, ever expected positive content to be more profitable than negative content! In hindsight, however, after thinking about it a bit, it kind of makes sense. I'm now wondering, could advertising perhaps become (gasp) a force for good, at least in certain settings? NYT PREDICTED FEELINGS Optimistic (+) Inspired (+) Self-Confident (+) Amused (+) Adventurous (+) In the mood to spend ( ) Love (+) Sadness (-) Boredom ( ) Interest (+) Fear (-) Hate (-) Hope (+) Happiness (+) Nostalgic ( ) Indulgent ( ) Competitive (+) Informed (+)
- matt4077 8y agoIt has always been known that certain content would work better to sell ads than other. Travel, cooking, or home decoration, for example, are definitely better than political news. And yet, the NYT has withstood the pressure to become the ground level equivalent of an in-flight magazine. Can we maybe credit them for that, instead of just assuming that everybody agrees that they will succumb to economic pressure without feeling the need to even make the case for it?
- adw 8y agoThe news industry has been aware of this forever; one of the fundamental problems with news being ad-supported is that advertisers don't want their ads next to bad news. This predates the Internet; it's why glossy Sunday sections exist.
- sremani 8y agoThis is not particular to NYT but when your news sources are A/B testing and have information on your feelings, they will happily make up the news to reinforce your confirmation bias. The Royal Society's motto "nulius in verba" is becoming more true by day.
- soared 8y ago> they will happily make up the news How are you possibly making that claim? There is nothing to support that.
- zarkov99 8y agoIf there was any question that the NYT is not a newspaper, at least in the pre-internet sense of the word, this should put it to rest. The same kind of shenanigans are at play in every news outlet I can think off. How does one make sense of such a vast world when telling the truth is not profitable?
- narrator 8y agoGood! I can't wait till I have a browser plugin that will tell me what my mood will be after reading a news article. You could make it an add-on to RescueTime. One could limit depressing or enraging news articles to 10 minutes a week.
- taurath 8y agoI wonder how much they’re hacking the “Popular” section in the app to increase ad revenue. I notice that absolutely 0 of their top stories are ever at the top popular article list - usually travel, opinion and health, which presumably has more high traffic ads. They’re also messing with the scroller - it will stop scrolling on an ad to make sure it loads.
- bonestamp2 8y agoOn one hand, I like this because it might skew "news" production toward positive news stories. On the other hand, I dislike it because the news should just be the news and the business of the news should not skew the content of the news. But, that's probably too much to ask these days.
- kylek 8y agoNYTimes is the main reason I've been on the search for some kind of feature for HN (addon? greasemonkey script? ANYTHING) to auto-hide articles based on domain or title matches. Does anyone have a solution?
- krastanov 8y agoIt is difficult for me to see this as not being naive. Yes, the editorial staff of any newspaper would have opinions, and even worse, implicit biases. 1: that does not mean that the firewall between journalists and editorial is being broken casually; 2: you correct for bias by using diverse journalistic sources (and removing only the worse offenders like say Breitbart or Infowars), not by completely disregarding information from imperfect sources.
- nicky0 8y agoNot to mention that if you disregarded all imperfect sources, you would have no news.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- kylek 8y agoLikely just me, but nearly every title of a NYT article that shows up here elicits some kind of emotional response in me. I can't tell anymore if they're expertly crafted or that I've just become really sensitive to it. At this point I'm happy to throw the baby out with the bathwater. I'm just looking for tech news, man! I don't want to be prompted to get out the pitchfork every time I browse HN.
- yorwba 8y agoIn theory you could filter out articles based on the emotions the NYT thinks the article will elicit in you. Of course the advertising classification might turn out to be imperfect.
- 8y ago
- jameslk 8y agoSounds like a great conflict of interest. Emotional manipulation will become a metric to optimize. Depending on what the content manipulates you into feeling, you may sell more ads. This leads to more manipulative content since it's what sells more ads. As an alternative to current targeted advertising, this seems much worse. At least I can block ads and trackers. I can't block content that's been engineered to manipulate.
- WhatIsDukkha 8y agoI agree. From the article - """Journalists and other news purists may also wonder whether the Times newsroom is now being tasked with producing lots of emotional stories. Neither is the case, Allison Murphy, senior vice president of advertising innovation, told me in an interview.""" If this isn't a lie already it will be in a few months. The simplistic counterargument is that writers do this already but as we know... once we have numbers to target the optimizations will kick in. This won't end well :P
- return0 8y agodoesnt bloomberg already reward articles that shake the markets? (at least thats a rumour)
- HuShifang 8y agoBet the Financial Times doesn't do this. (See https://www.cjr.org/special_report/why-the-left-cant-stand-the-new-york-times.php https://www.cjr.org/special_report/why-the-left-cant-stand-t... -- whatever your politics she makes a fair point)