4 ms·
They intentionally seek to publish a range of opinions in the opinion section. That some of them are contradictory is consistent with that goal.
by maxerickson 8y ago
They intentionally seek to publish a range of opinions in the opinion section.
That some of them are contradictory is consistent with that goal.
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoI do agree, and while this is an independent opinion piece, is worth noting that the author is a member of the NYT editorial board.
- thirdsun 8y agoAnd that prohibits him from expressing his individual perspective? I don't see any reason why a newspaper should have to talk with a singular, homogeneous voice.
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoNot at all, and I didn't make that argument. But as a member of the editorial staff, he has put his name behind numerous editorials railing against Facebook and their impact on personal privacy (just google "New York times editorial Facebook privacy" for many examples). Given that, I found the author's brushing aside of privacy concerns in this article ("it's government information, not personal information" - yeah, that the government requires everyone to provide or else they put you in jail) extremely weak.
- bko 8y agoNot all opinions are equal. Much like a newspaper doesn't (and shouldn't) give an equal platform to an anti-vaccine advocate as they do a scientist, I think these kinds of opinions are so vile that they do not deserve publication, at least not in NYT. The bar should be higher. It's essentially a piece promoting a policy that would be probably the single largest attack on the right to privacy in the history of the US. Why? Because a president the author doesn't like refused to release his tax returns. Very measured response. I'm sure there would be no unintended consequences.
- javagram 8y ago> so vile that they do not deserve publication It’s a policy that’s standard in several Northern European nations generally recognized as civilized and a good place to live. You may consider it vile but from the perspective of the NY editorial board I don’t see why they would.
- distances 8y ago> I think these kinds of opinions are so vile that they do not deserve publication, at least not in NYT. This is ridiculous. I'm from a country with public tax records, and wholeheartedly support it. It definitely needs to be part of discussion when deciding how to tackle tax avoidance, corruption, and wealth disparity. I've never checked my friends' or colleagues' taxes, even if I could. It's quite important that the tax records of the notable figures are public though.
- akimball 8y agoAnd people get killed by extortionists, or live in cages, as a result of destroying privacy rights. You can't have freedom without privacy